The high incidence rate of the O VI λλ1032, 1038 absorption around low-redshift, ∼L * star-forming galaxies has generated interest in studies of the circumgalactic medium. We use the high-resolution EAGLE cosmological simulation to analyze the circumgalactic O VI gas around z ≈ 0.3 star-forming galaxies. Motivated by the limitation that observations do not reveal where the gas lies along the lineof-sight, we compare the O VI measurements produced by gas within fixed distances around galaxies and by gas selected using line-of-sight velocity cuts commonly adopted by observers. We show that gas selected by a velocity cut of ±300 km s −1 or ±500 km s −1 produces a higher O VI column density, a flatter column density profile, and a higher covering fraction compared to gas within one, two, or three times the virial radius (r vir ) of galaxies. The discrepancy increases with impact parameter and worsens for lower mass galaxies. For example, compared to the gas within 2r vir , identifying the gas using velocity cuts of 200-500 km s −1 increases the O VI column density by 0.2 dex (0.1 dex) at 1r vir to over 0.75 dex (0.7 dex) at ≈ 2r vir for galaxies with stellar masses of 10 9 -10 9.5 M (10 10 -10 10.5 M ). We furthermore estimate that excluding O VI outside r vir decreases the circumgalactic oxygen mass measured by Tumlinson et al. (2011) by over 50%. Our results demonstrate that gas at large lineof-sight separations but selected by conventional velocity windows has significant effects on the O VI measurements and may not be observationally distinguishable from gas near the galaxies.