The relationship between social desirability bias and self-reports of health, substance use, and social network factors among urban substance users in Baltimore, Maryland

Abstract

Background Social desirability response bias may lead to inaccurate self-reports and erroneous study conclusions. The present study examined the relationship between social desirability response bias and self-reports of mental health, substance use, and social network factors among a community sample of inner-city substance users. Methods The study was conducted in a sample of 591 opiate and cocaine users in Baltimore, Maryland from 2009–2013. Modified items from the Marlowe-Crowne Social Desirability Scale were included in the survey, which was conducted face-to-face and using Audio Computer Self Administering Interview (ACASI) methods. Results There were highly statistically significant differences in levels of social desirability response bias by levels of depressive symptoms, drug use stigma, physical health status, recent opiate and cocaine use, Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT) scores, and size of social networks. There were no associations between health service utilization measures and social desirability bias. In multiple logistic regression models, even after including the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) as a measure of depressive symptomology, social desirability bias was associated with recent drug use and drug user stigma. Social desirability bias was not associated with enrollment in prior research studies. Conclusions These findings suggest that social desirability bias is associated with key health measures and that the associations are not primarily due to depressive symptoms. Methods are needed to reduce social desirability bias. Such methods may include the wording and prefacing of questions, clearly defining the role of “study participant,” and assessing and addressing motivations for socially desirable responses.

Alcohol Use and Long‐Term Outcomes Among U.S. Veterans Who Received Direct‐Acting Antivirals for Hepatitis C Treatment

“…Third, despite the use of a validated screening tool, AUDIT-C screening done at a given time point is still selfreported and may not accurately reflect levels of alcohol consumption in an individual due to recall bias or social desirability bias. (30) However, as AUDIT-C scores were not linked to HCV or treatment in our cohort, our patients were more likely to be truthful in their report. We were also able to improve our assessment of alcohol use by obtaining AUDIT-C scores over time (1 year before and at least 3 months after treatment completion) and incorporating time-varying covariate modeling in our analysis.…”

Quality indicators and community pharmacy services: a scoping review

“…The use of objective, reliable data is a challenge associated with the quality measurement of community pharmacy practice. Self‐report is common and is likely to be associated with social desirability bias . Pharmacy dispensing or claims data have been investigated to derive quality indicators and as a method for avoiding self‐assessment .…”

Effect of a dialogue-based intervention on psychosocial well-being 6 months after stroke in Norway: A randomized controlled trial

“…Social desirability bias (35) is another factor that potentially affected the results. If the respondents had acted in ways or held attitudes that they felt were undesirable, their answers might have been affected.…”