The relationship between women’s presence in corporate positions and firm performance

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to analyze, in the Colombian developing context, the relationship between the presence of women in corporate positions and the financial performance of the company and to know if there are differences between family and non-family firms. Design/methodology/approach Building on the contingency theory of leadership, which emphasizes that leader’s personality and the situation in which that leader operates influences corporate decision-making, the authors use panel data models on a sample of 54 Colombian public businesses for the period 2008-2015 to test the proposed hypotheses on the relationship between women´s presence in corporate governance positions and financial performance, as well as the difference between family and non-family firms. Findings The results support that women´s presence in corporate governance positions is positively associated with firm performance. More concretely, the authors find a relationship between women at the top corporate governance structure (as part of the board of directors, top management team and chief executive officer) and firm profitability. Results also indicate that family business, as a type of organization, (negatively) moderates the positive relationship between female participation in top executive positions (board and top executive team) and firm performance. Research limitations/implications First, this study is limited to women in corporate positions in large companies listed on the Colombia Stock Exchange, and thus, generalizability for smaller entities may be limited. Second, data limitations do not allow us to investigate ways in which women’s presence in corporate governance structures contributes to improve firm goals. Practical implications The authors provide support to the hypothesis that positively relates women’s presence in corporate governance positions and firm performance for the case of Colombia. This serves as a guidance to Colombian regulators, corporate decision-makers and policy-makers to promote the inclusion of women in top hierarchical structures through either mandatory laws or recommendation. Originality/value Few studies have addressed the women´s presence in corporate governance positions and contribution to firm performance in developing economies. This study contributes to better understand how women impact performance in contexts where women are underrepresented in corporate governance structure and where there are no laws that pressure firms to appoint women in corporate governance positions.

Does Gender Representation at Decision Making Levels Matter for Better Financial Performance of Local Licensed Commercial Banks in Sri Lanka?

“…Accordingly, the above scholars concluded that there was no association between the aforesaid two variables. However, a positive relationship between the variables was found in one study which was based on the ROA ratio measure [13]. Similar results were obtained in a study carried out on 112 US companies [43].…”

“…The ROA has been used as an accounting based measurement of firm financial performance in terms of profitability. ROA has been used in most previous studies which have focused on the relationship between females employed at the decision making level and firm financial performance [5,7,[11][12][13][14].…”

Social Sustainability on Corporate Boards: The Effects of Female Family Members on R&D

“…A diversified board might provide diverse perspectives and points of view as a means of enriching the strategic role of the board, and overcome risk-averse tendencies [52] that could jeopardize innovation. Gender is one of these characteristics related to the board composition, in which diversity could be translated into better governance [60]. It is also a topic that has recently been widely discussed because increasing the representation of women in the upper corporate echelons is considered a matter of social sustainability, entailing social justice and equity, and avoiding the restrictions on women occupying highly responsibility positions in companies.…”

Effect of Composition of Board and Promoter Group Retained Ownership on Underpricing of Indian IPO firms: An Empirical Study

“…Since IPO firms have to manage the perceptions of potential investors and at the same time signal their good quality, the hypothesis which stands to be tested is whether the presence of female directors has any contribution in mitigating information asymmetry and ultimately checking the underpricing. Although several studies can be found that examine the impact of female directors on performance of firm, for example, a recent one by Moreno-Gómez and Calleja-Blanco (2018) conducted in Colombia found a positive association between the two. Yet there is a dearth of research examining the impact of female directors on underpricing of IPOs, that is, the aim here is to see how market reacts to a female presence on the board.…”