The relationships between collective-oriented values and materialism, product status signaling and product satisfaction

Abstract

Purpose Prior research has found that consumers’ purchasing behavior varies amongst consumers of different cultures. The purpose of this paper is to examine the behavior of consumers of luxury products by investigating the relationships between their collective-oriented values (pertaining to religion, family, and community), and their materialism or materialistic orientation, resulting in them using such products to signal their social status to others, and whether they are getting satisfaction from using such products, in an effort to understand how the behaviors vary between Malaysian and Saudi Arabian consumers. Design/methodology/approach Data were collected by a questionnaire survey where 1,388 self-administered questionnaires were collected from Baby boomers, Generations X and Y respondents in two major cities: Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia and Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. The data were analyzed using structural equation modeling. The authors also assessed the structure and reliability of the constructs developed for this research as well as tested some hypotheses regarding their interrelationships, across the two different cities/cultures. Findings Findings demonstrate the complexity of cultures and lifestyles of consumers and societies. For Saudi consumers, their materialistic tendency is significantly influenced by their religious, family values (inverse relationship), and community values, whereas for the Malaysian consumers, this tendency was only significantly influenced by their family values. For the Saudis, there were strong positive relationships between materialistic values and product status signaling and between product status signaling and product satisfaction, whereas for the Malaysians, both relationships were also positive but only moderate in strength. Overall, the results show that the Malaysians were more materialistic than the Saudis. But, since the Saudis have higher income, they are in a better position to fulfill their materialistic desire than their Malaysian counterparts. Research limitations/implications The convenience sampling used for the study is the main limitation. Another limitation of this study is that it was done in only one major city in each of the two countries. Practical implications Consumers from the two cultures/cities do use luxury products to signal their status in the society, despite their different cultures and country income levels and that the consumption of those products gave both of them satisfaction. Hence, as a practical implication, international marketers of luxury products and services could and should continue to market their products and services in these two countries. However, they need to understand that the factors that influence the consumers’ materialism are different between the two cultures/cities and hence their marketing strategies need to take this into consideration. Originality/value All the issues discussed in this study have not been previously empirically investigated and compared in two different developing countries – Saudi Arabia, a mono-cultural and high-income country) and Malaysia (a multi-cultural and upper middle income country) despite their rapid growth rates and economic importance.

The effect of materialism on conspicuous vs inconspicuous luxury consumption: focused on need for uniqueness, self-monitoring and self-construal

“…Previous research shows that self-concept and feelings/thoughts about selves affect luxury consumption (Ko et al , 2019). The concept of self is important (Kastanakis and Balabanis, 2012) because materialistic consumers use luxury products to construct and enhance their self-concept (Hudders and Pandelaere, 2012; Sharda and Bhat, 2018; Kassim et al , 2016). The focus of this study is to reveal how the self would be extended depending on self-construal and how the self has impact on luxury brand consumption distinctively.…”

Materialism and compulsive buying behaviour

“…An orientation towards materialistic values is viewed as central to the current consumer culture (Kasser and Kanner, 2004). However, factors that influence consumers' materialism vary across cultures (Kassim et al, 2016).…”

Board gender composition and marketing effectiveness in the female consumer market in Zimbabwe

“…In line with the above, Kassim et al (2016) suggest that manufacturing corporate entities should understand the symbolic meaning attached to their products and brands by the female consumers to achieve marketing effectiveness. Accordingly, knowledge of the symbolic meaning attached to their products is likely to assist the manufacturer design appropriate marketing activities that are consistent with the meaning.…”

“…D’Antone and Merunka (2015) argue that consumers from developing countries perceive products from developed countries as of higher quality than their own locally produced products. Consumers from developing countries will therefore tend to spend more on imported products than home produced products (Kassim et al , 2016). To support the latter view, a research by Lee et al (2015) finds Chinese female consumers as preferring imported juices to locally produced ones.…”