The responsibility of an ethnocentric consumer – nationalistic, patriotic or environmentally conscientious? A critical discourse analysis of “buy domestic” campaigns

Abstract

PurposeThe study examines the responsibilisation of an ethnocentric consumer in commercial, meta-organisational discourses. In addition to nationalistic and patriotic discourses, the focus is on wider conceptualisations of consumer responsibility.Design/methodology/approachThe paper uses critical discourse analysis as a methodological approach to conduct an empirical case study on the texts of two producer-driven labelling campaigns.FindingsThe campaign texts create possibilities for ethnocentric consumption with positioning, argumentative and classificatory discourses. Patriotic responsibilisation is emphasised, together with rationales to take action on environmental concerns.Practical implicationsThe study highlights the responsibility of marketers over their corporate responsibility communication, suggesting that ethnocentric promotions may have the power to alter how consumers take action on various responsibility concerns.Social implicationsThe study surfaces the tensions that responsible consumption can entail for consumers. Indeed, nationalistic and patriotic discourses may alter our understanding of responsibility issues that may seem completely separate from the concepts of nationalism and patriotism.Originality/valueThe paper shows how different organisational texts are deployed to bring about the idea of ethnocentric consumption and how this relates to responsibility discourses, nationalism and patriotism.

Environmental and Political Determinants of Food Choices: A Preliminary Study in a Croatian Sample

“…Political and economic factors are often more important than environmental. Therefore, commercial or state-led "buy domestic" campaigns often mention protecting domestic jobs and the national economy, not environmental protection [40]. Correspondingly, the "Let's Buy Croatian" campaign led by the Croatian Chamber of Economy calls for promotion and development of a prosperous and competitive Croatian economy and highlights the importance of saving jobs [41].…”

The influence of feelings on the Chinese generation Z's consumer behavior of electronic products — based on the moderating effect of 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics

“…Among these questions, age was the screening item, because this paper only needs to collect the questionnaire results from generation Z, whose age is between 13 -28. The second part examined the degree of patriotism and ethnocentrism of the respondents, as well as their sense of pride, superiority and belonging, which were modified by Harris and Dacin (2019); Pekkanen and Penttilä (2021) and Pekkanen and Penttilä (2021) respectively. The following part was about the respondents' attention to the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics.…”

“…The existing study shows that, national pride will increase consumers' willingness and intention to buy local products to a certain extent . Last but not the least, according to Pekkanen and Penttilä (2021) in consumption, the sense of superiority shown by ethnocentrism tends to be a sense of exclusion from foreign products and believes that domestic products are supreme, which means the sense of superiority will also promote the consumption of domestic products. Thus, this study made the following hypotheses.…”

Cultivating Patriotism—A Pioneering Note on a Russian Dimension of Corporate Ethics Management

“…Patriotism can be also regarded as a mechanism by which the state guides corporate ethics in the correct way. Nonetheless, the discourses of patriotism and responsibility do not necessarily agree in all (Pekkanen and Penttilä 2021).…”