The Rise of Socially Responsible Investment Funds: The Paradoxical Role of the Financial Logic

Abstract

Socially responsible investing (SRI) is gaining traction in the financial sector, but it is unclear whether the dominant financial logic complements or competes with the social logic in the founding of SRI funds. Based on insights we gained from observation at an Asian SRI industry association, interviews with SRI professionals in the U.S. and Europe, and other fieldwork, we questioned explanations for SRI's conflicted relationship with the financial logic. Our observations prompted us to build a panel database of SRI fund foundings from 1970 to 2014 in 19 countries so that we could examine how a dominant logic interacts with alternative logics to promote or stifle institutional change. We decomposed the financial logic into interdependent dimensions as the provider of means (resources, practices, and knowledge) for novel financial ventures to be founded and the enforcer of profit-maximizing ends that constrain such foundings. Our theory suggests a paradoxical role for the financial logic, which explains an intriguing empirical finding: the founding of SRI funds has a curvilinear, inverted-U-shaped relationship with the prevalence of the financial logic. We propose and find that the relationship between the dominant financial logic and the social logic of SRI shifts from complementary to competing as the financial logic becomes more prevalent in society and its profit-maximizing end becomes taken for granted. We examined how certain alternative logicsthose of unions, religion, and green political parties-moderate these effects. Our results shed light on how and to what extent institutional change can occur in fields in which one institutional logic is dominant. They also reveal countrylevel institutional factors that drive SRI.

An Institutional Approach to Gender Diversity and Firm Performance

“…These characteristics make these firms an ideal setting for examining how the institutional environment moderates investors', workers', and managers' approaches to gender diversity. I gathered gender composition and financial data on each firm from Bloomberg, a widely used financial database that provides company profiles and financial statements (Yan, Ferraro, and Almandoz 2018). Bloomberg collects workforce diversity information from firms' annual reports.…”

Discrete Time Ruin Probability for Takaful (Islamic Insurance) with Investment and Qard-Hasan (Benevolent Loan) Activities

“…It incorporates non-financial concerns such as social, environmental, and moral issues as part of the investment decision, in addition to the financial return. Religion, besides union and green political parties, is one of the the most commonly studied in the SRI context (Yan et al 2019). Islamic finance is a class of SRI that complies with the principles of the Quran (Holy Book of Islam), the Hadith (teachings and sayings of Prophet Muhammad), and Ijtihad (scholarly legal deductions).…”

Categorical cognition and outcome efficiency in impact investing decisions

“…Early research on impact investing has examined issues such as investor willingness to accept tradeoffs between social and financial goals (Barber et al, ) and the antecedents of new impact investment funds (Arjaliès & Durand, ; Yan, Ferraro, & Almandoz, ), but to our knowledge it has not examined impact investors' actual capital allocation decisions. Yet we believe it is important to do so, given research in both contexts of traditional investing (Benartzi & Thaler, ) and charitable giving (Small, Loewenstein, & Slovic, ) showing that behavioral limitations often limit decision‐makers from achieving their objectives.…”