The role of audit quality and culture influence on earnings management in companies with excessive free cash flow

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to examine the effect of culture and audit quality on managers’ decisions regarding accounting accruals. It focuses on companies experiencing excessive free cash flow, as these companies have been associated with an agency problem. Design/methodology/approach This study measures the magnitude of discretionary accruals as a proxy for earnings management using the cross-sectional modified Jones model. Excessive free cash flow is scrutinized by the method used by Chung et al. (2005). Listed companies in nine countries in the Asia-Pacific region are represented in this study. The statistical analyses are used to examine the influence of cultural aspect, the role of external monitoring by high-quality auditors and the earnings management practice in the companies with excessive free-cash-flow. Findings The empirical results presented in this paper provide support for the proposition that managers of companies with excessive free-cash-flow will make investment decisions that are not always in the best interest of the shareholders and use accounting discretion to increase reported earnings. This study provides empirical evidence that these companies have been associated with an agency problem and the role of external auditor persists in a setting, where cultural differences prevail in across countries. Practical implications In cross-border trade and investment, the findings provide the opportunity to exploit a setting, where cultural differences prevail, whereas other potentially influential variables, including the role of external monitoring by high-quality auditors, are relatively constant across countries. Originality/value Previous studies (Leuz et al., 2003; and Enomoto et al., 2015) examine factors influencing earnings management internationally have concentrated on legal institutions and investor protection. Han et al. (2010) completed a cross-country study on the effects of national culture on earnings management. This study focuses on companies across countries experiencing with excessive free cash flow and examines the cultural aspect and the effectiveness of external monitoring by high-quality auditors operating in different countries in mitigating managerial opportunism.

Investor Decision in Estimating the Effect of Earning Persistence, Financial Leverage, Foreign Ownership Toward Company Reputation and Company Value

“…Furthermore Lennox et al (2016) says that a measure, accrual accounting, is the main indicator of earnings quality. Astami et al (2017) described the differences in the company's accounting earnings and the underlying cash flow. Large positive accruals indicate that earnings are higher than the cash flow obtained by the company.…”

Audit and tax in the context of emerging technologies: A retrospective analysis, current trends, and future opportunities

“…Many studies documented the benefit of using a combination of structured and unstructured data in audit evidence (Janvrin & Weidenmier Watson, 2017;Astami et al, 2017). Tang and Karim (2019) found that an auditor's use of unstructured data is still limited and thus recommended upgrading the practitioners' skills to manage the data variety, velocity, volume, veracity, and value.…”

Earnings management in V4 countries: the evidence of earnings smoothing and inflating

“…The authors declare that earnings management increases when accounting data directly affect the magnitude of tariffs imposed on the trade investigation and decreases with the increasing number of petitioning enterprises. Astami et al (2017) investigate the role of culture and audit quality on managerial decisions regarding accounting accruals using the cross-sectional modified Jones model. The interrelationships between national culture and accounting practices were revealed also in the research of Paredes and Wheatley, (2017) and Ferramosca and Allegrini (2018).…”