The Role of Law Enforcement Officers/Police in Drug Prevention within Educational Settings—Study Protocol for the Development of a Guiding Document Based on Experts’ Opinions

Abstract

The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime—World Health Organization International Standards on Drug Use Prevention—reflects the value of safe, nurturing and supportive social institutions around the lives of youths to benefit from the prevention of risky behavior extending beyond individually-developed resilience for healthy adolescent development. Schools are valuable social institutions to this effect and school safety and adolescent health outcomes can be threatened by drug use and violence. As such, collaborative, multi-level, evidence-based, developmentally sensitive, substance use prevention programs are imperative. The International Standards, in their latest version, did not reflect specific evidence of law enforcement officer-based programs with effect on drug use prevention, including in school settings. Nevertheless, the collaboration between law enforcement agencies and school-based substance use prevention programs continue to be the focus of research and policy. In this project, we aim to explore in more detail the role of law enforcement in preventing substance use in schools. We use mixed methods, including three phases: (i) scoping review on the best practices for effective law enforcement in school-based drug and crime prevention; (ii) interviews with experts, using the Delphi method, in substance use prevention and training law enforcement in school-based drug prevention; and iii) developing guidelines for law enforcement based on the findings. Initially, we identified a total of 17 papers that were categorized in four categories based on their results (negative or null effect n = 11 studies, positive effect n = 1 study, mixed effects n = 4 studies and indefinite conclusion n = 1 study). However, the authors of the studies with negative or null effect did recommend being cautious about these results due to the respective studies’ methodological limitations. The actual and perceived roles of police are largely unclear and/or variable. Therefore, clear outlines regarding law enforcement’s role within schools are crucial as one study showed that an officer’s role influences how they respond to student conduct. A secondary emergent theme from this review indicates that there is potential for positively impacting a youth’s perceptions of police through collaborative and engaging school-based programs. Currently the project is gradually moving to Phase II, where we are identifying the key experts based on scientifically published peer reviewed and grey literature/guidelines to investigate elements that make the role of law enforcement officers in school-based prevention more effective. Given the frequency with which policy makers around the world request information about the role of law enforcement in effective prevention efforts, guidelines on their roles within schools is a gap that needs to be filled. Such efforts would improve drug prevention in schools and better orient law enforcement’s role in drug prevention within educational settings.

Teaching, learning, and assessment of law on medical students' cognitive, affective and psychomotor skills: a systematic review

“…However, in the last decade, studies have primarily believed in separating ethical concepts from legal ones in medical education [18, 35, 67-72] and others were examined separately [73][74][75][76][77].…”

Revisão sistemática sobre o efeito do programa escolar de prevenção ao uso de drogas Keepin’ it REAL: traduzido e implementado no Brasil pelo PROERD

“…Desta forma, parece inadequado utilizar como evidência de sucesso para a disseminação do PROERD outros currículos do kiR que não a mesma versão que vem sendo utilizada no Brasil: a versão adaptada pelo DARE americano (DARE-kiR). Destaca-se ainda que a versão DARE-kiR é implementada por policiais uniformizados, enquanto todas as outras versões avaliadas (reportadas nessa revisão) são implementadas por professores e outros profissionais da escola, sendo que a influência dos policias na prevenção ao uso de drogas ainda não é totalmente clara, necessitando mais estudos nessa área 35 . Importante mencionar que existe um estudo publicado reportando dados de avalição de efetividade do DARE-kiR nas escolas americanas, no entanto ele não preencheu critérios para ser analisado nessa revisão por se tratar de um estudo com desenho quasi-experimental, que avaliou o efeito do programa em desfechos secundários (não no uso de drogas e/ou violência).…”

Pakistan's War on Drugs: Examining the Integral Contributions of Police and Prosecution in Narcotics Trials

“…In order to guarantee that the accused receives adequate legal advice, that their rights to due process and a fair trial are respected, and that their rights to competent legal representation are maintained, this may entail close collaboration with a defence attorney. s In order to guarantee that the accused receives adequate legal advice, that their rights to due process and a fair trial are respected, and that their rights to competent legal representation are maintained, this may entail close collaboration with defence attorneys (El-Khatib, Herrera, Campello, Mattfeld, & Maalouf, 2021). Since they are in charge of making sure that drugrelated offences are properly prosecuted and that justice is done, prosecutors are crucial players in drug cases.…”