The role of meteorological forcing and snow model complexity in winter glacier mass balance estimation, Columbia River basin, Canada

Abstract

Glaciers are commonly located in mountainous terrain subject to highly variable meteorological conditions. High resolution meteorological (HRM) data simulated by atmospheric models can complement meteorological station observations in order to assess changes in glacier energy fluxes and mass balance. We examine the performance of two snow models, SnowModel and Alpine3D, forced by different meteorological data for winter mass balance simulations at four glaciers in the Canadian portion of the Columbia Basin. The Weather Research and Forecasting model (WRF) with resolution of 1 km and the North American Land Data Assimilation System with 12 km resolution, provide HRM data for the two snow models. Evaluation is based on the ability of the snow models to simulate snow depth at both point locations (automated snow weather stations) and over the entire glacier surface (airborne LiDAR [Light Detection and Ranging] surveys) during the 2015/2016 winter accumulation. When forced with HRM data, both models can reproduce snow depth to within ±15% of observed values. Both models underestimate winter mass balance when forced by HRM data. When driven with WRF data, SnowModel underestimates winter mass balance integrated over the glacier area by 1 and 10%, whilst Alpine3D underestimates winter mass balance by 12 and 22% compared with LiDAR and stake measurements, respectively. The overall results show that SnowModel forced by WRF simulated winter mass balance the best.

Inishell 2.0: semantically driven automatic GUI generation for scientific models

“…When using numerical models, one of the major issues for new users is the configuration of the model (Jamieson et al, 2010;Schlögl et al, 2016;Mortezapour et al, 2020). Often the numerical models are configured using multiple configuration files filled with obscure configuration parameters, making for a steep learning curve.…”

Reply on RC2

“…Due to the sparse distribution of in situ observations globally, regional weather forecast models are recently used to estimate the amount of SWE (Klehmet et al, 2013;Wrzesien et al 2017;Raparelli et al, 2021). Although there have been many studies that evaluate temperature and precipitation simulations over North America (Diaconescu et al, 2016;Xu et al, 60 2019;Holtzman et al, 2020), few studies have been performed regionally to validate the model estimation of the spatial and temporal patterns in SWE using ground-based observation (e.g., Alonso-González et al 2018;Mortezapour et al, 2020, Yang et al 2023.…”

Evaluation of surface mass-balance records using geodetic data and physically-based modelling, Place and Peyto glaciers, western Canada

“…Finally, mass balance can also be estimated using physically-based models that differ in their level of complexity (e.g. Hock, 1999; Huss and others, 2009; Radić and others, 2015; Clarke and others, 2015; Mortezapour and others, 2020).…”