“…Whereas, the data with higher δ 13 C values (about 1.5‰, VPDB; Fig. 12) probably indicate carbon derivation within microbial methanogenesis zone, bacterial fermentation and contribution from atmospheric CO 2 (Irwin and Hurst, 1983;Morad et al, 1998 (Bjørlykke, 2014;Burley and Kantorowicz, 1986;Giles, 1987;Schmidt, 1979;Taylor et al, 2010). Perhaps more importantly is whether there are sufficient organic acid to dissolve the carbonate cements or significant fluid flow with undersaturated solutions to replenish the system (e.g.…”