Solvent
effects in synthetic chemistry can be analyzed in various
ways, but a possibly counterintuitive approach is to remove the solvent
entirely from the reaction environment. Mechanochemical initiation
(grinding or milling of solid reagents) can then be used to replace
the mixing and energy that would be supplied by a solvent. The effect
of complete solvent elimination can be unpredictable, however, and
even partial removal, as found in the realm of liquid-assisted grinding
(LAG), can alter reaction outcomes profoundly. Reduced quantities
of solvents can also be present in the form of solvates, and although
their use has been classified under the category of “neat”
or “dry” grinding, “solvate-assisted grinding”
(SAG) might be a more descriptive term, as the outcome of such reactions
can differ from those of both LAG and neat grinding, with the latter
term more properly restricted to the use of anhydrous or unsolvated
reagents only. This study examines the mechanochemically driven synthesis
of the bis(allyl)metal complexes [MA′2] (M = Cr,
Fe, Co, Ni; A′ = 1,3-(SiMe3)2C3H3) via halide metathesis. Particular emphasis is given
to the nickel-based system, whose synthesis from nickel halide solvates
is compared with the same reaction using the anhydrous metal halide
and either large or LAG quantities of solvent (a few microliters of
solvent per milligram of reagents). The reactions employing solvate-assisted
grinding, either alone (e.g., with [Ni(py)4Cl2]) or with LAG amounts of a different solvent (e.g., with [Ni(dme)Br2] and THF as the LAG solvent) yield the nickel allyl complex
the most efficiently, suggesting that the intimate interaction of
coordinated solvents with the metal centers is an important variable
in determining the outcome of the metathesis reactions. Although they
were developed in the context of mechanochemically driven reactions,
these results have implications for solution-based synthesis as well,
where the use of solvated reagents can strongly affect outcomes.