The Role of Spirituality and Religiosity in Subjective Well-Being of Individuals With Different Religious Status

Abstract

Spirituality and religiosity have been found to be positive predictors of subjective well-being, even if results are not altogether consistent across studies. This mixed evidence is probably due to the inadequate operationalization of the constructs as well as the neglect of the moderation effect that the individuals’ religious status can have on the relation between spirituality/religiosity and subjective well-being. The current study aimed to investigate the relationship of spirituality and religiosity with subjective well-being (operationalized as both life satisfaction and balance between positive and negative affect) and to test whether differences exist according to individuals’ religious status (religious, non-religious, and uncertain). Data were collected from 267 Italian adults aged 18–77 ( M = 36.68; SD = 15.13), mainly women (59.9%). In order to test the role of spirituality (operationalized as Purpose, Innerness, Interconnection, and Transcendence) and religiosity (operationalized as three dimensions of the religious identity: Commitment, In-depth Exploration, and Reconsideration of Commitment) in subjective well-being, two path analysis models were run, one for each predictor. To test the invariance of the two models across the individuals’ religious status, two multi-group models were run. The models concerning spirituality were tested on the entire sample, finding that spirituality had a positive impact on subjective well-being (except for the dimension of Interconnection) and that this relation is unaffected by the individual’s religious status. The models concerning religiosity were instead tested only on religious and uncertain, finding that the relationship between religiosity and subjective well-being changes across religious status. In particular, the main difference we found was that religious identity commitment positively predicted satisfaction with life among religious, but not among uncertain individuals. An interpretation of the results and their implications are discussed.

Sociodemographic Factors’ Association with Community-Dwelling Older Adults’ Psychosocial Wellbeing: The Greek Context

“…church attendance) and subjective wellbeing Gartner, Larson, & Allen, 1991;Krause, 2011), particularly in old age (Krause & Hayward, 2016;Boey, 2003). Consistent with previous studies, religious engagement was found to have a positive impact both on the induction of positive emotions and on satisfaction with life, both among churchgoers per se and in terms of the spirituality domain of wellbeing, which fosters a greater sense of coherence and meaning in life (Villani, Sorgente, Iannello, & Antonietti, 2019;Von Humboldt et al, 2015). A study by Ellison (1991) has found that religious individuals with strong faith have higher levels of wellbeing, greater subjective happiness, and better psychosocial adjustment after stressful life events.…”

The Role of Well-Being, Spirituality, and Religiosity for Successful Aging in Late Life: A Brief Review

“…Religion can be conceptualized as a complex and multifaceted phenomenon involving elements of belief, behavior, community involvement, and social identity [30]. On the other hand, spirituality can be viewed as the search for interconnectedness with humanity and a personal need for connection with a higher power that can occur in and/or outside of a formal religious context [10]. A very large number of studies have found a relationship of religious and spiritual involvement with better psychological and health outcomes [31], with these effects often appearing more pronounced in later life [32].…”

“…Contrary to the negative myths that relate aging with declines in well-being, Carstensen and colleagues [9] suggest that older adulthood is a period of development where the well-being outcomes and emotional regulation of the elderly are improving compared to the middle-life because older adults tend to focus particularly on emotionally positive situations. Furthermore, a growing body of research reveals that involvement in religious activities affects spiritual well-being and may improve the elderly's overall psychological well-being and the way that they judge their life satisfaction [10].…”

Eat to Live, Don’t Live to Eat: Black Men, Masculinity, Faith and Food

“…Over the past several decades studies have highlighted the ways that religious involvement conceptualized as "observable feelings, beliefs, activities, and experiences in relation to the spiritual, divine, or supernatural" (p. 239, [12]) contributes to better health outcomes such a lowered risk of mortality [12,13]. Often, the terms, religion, spirituality, and faith are used interchangeably within health literature [30]. Within the context of this paper, I will rely on the term "faith" to discuss spiritual-religiosity as "seeking guidance about one's behavior from God, a higher power, spirit, religious texts, or leaders; having belief in, relationship with or connection with any of the entities referenced above" [7].…”