The Role of Strategic Autonomy in the EU Green Transition

Abstract

The European Green Deal (EGD) is the cornerstone of a strategic package (EGD Strategic Framework; EGDSF), which aims to make the EU a climate-neutral and competitive economy by 2050. The green transition planned by the EGD has been affected by relevant external shocks, which have highlighted Europe’s vulnerabilities in key strategic sectors. In this context, EU strategic autonomy (SA) has increasingly become a recurring element of the EGDSF. This article aims to provide a better understanding of the role of SA within the EGDSF and investigate whether it supports the EGD’s environmental ambitions. Based on an in-depth qualitative analysis of the EGDSF, it examines the specific purposes that, via SA, the EU wants to achieve and provides a categorisation of the related implementation measures. It emerges that SA objectives embedded into the EGDSF have been shaped in support of EGD goals but that some trade-offs may arise depending on the implementation measures selected to meet the former. In particular, current measures that promote self-sufficiency and the extension of environmental requirements to foreign businesses/products accessing the EU market raise some environmental, economic, and social concerns, which can be partly addressed through a stronger and more comprehensive EGD external dimension.

A Spotlight on Environmental Sustainability in View of the European Green Deal

“…Their work suggested that, despite the EGD's transformative intentions towards a sustainable European Union (EU), it may only partially achieve its objectives due to an underlying emphasis on economic growth that could overshadow environmental considerations. This analysis raises important questions about the depth and effectiveness of the EGD's approach to sustainability, echoing concerns that it might repeat the shortcomings of previous EU efforts in sustainable planning [50].…”