The role of task similarity for ego depletion: A registered report

Abstract

Ego depletion refers to decrements in self-control performance resulting from prior use of self-control. The ego depletion effect has received much research attention, but the more recent literature reports small or null effects. This registered report examined the moderating effect of task similarity on the ego depletion effect. We predicted a crossover interaction between type of primary and secondary task such that engaging in a demanding self-control task should lead to better performance in the secondary task when it is similar to the primary task (facilitation effect) but worse performance when it is dissimilar (ego depletion). In a preregistered pilot study, N = 80 participants first completed either a visual stop-signal task (SST) or a simple lexical categorization task. They proceeded with one of four tasks classified as increasingly dissimilar based on their underlying operations and executive functions: (1) auditory stop-signal task, (2) Stroop task, (3) Eriksen flanker task, and (4) unsolvable anagrams. Both the pilot study and a high-powered registered replication (N = 300) revealed the predicted interaction effect. However, evidence for facilitation from similar tasks was stronger than evidence for depletion from dissimilar tasks. Together, these findings highlight the important role of task similarity for the study of ego depletion and related phenomena.

Strategic thinking in the shadow of self-enhancement: Benefits and costs

“…We used two approaches to hypothesis testing (Primoceri et al, 2021) with the general expectation that they would yield converging conclusions (Krueger & Heck, 2018).…”

Perceiving emotions in music: Effects of sound quality, alexithymia, and empathy

“…We correlated all three facets of alexithymia (i.e., identifying emotions, verbalizing emotions, and externally oriented thinking) with empathy's three facets (i.e., perspective taking, fantasy, empathic concern, and personal distress). As our analytical approach, we used a combinatory framework of hypothesis testing inspired by Primoceri et al (2021) comprising both frequentist and Bayesian statistics. While it may be expected that the two approaches will yield converging conclusions regarding the hypotheses, the ongoing debate surrounding their relative merits warrants their parallel usage (Krueger & Heck, 2018).…”

Metaverse-based virtual reality experience and endurance performance in sports economy: Mediating role of mental health and performance anxiety

“…This is connected to low rates of official athlete mental health screening protocols ( 24 ). As a result of the immaturity of sports psychiatry and its research base ( 26 , 31 ), the mental health care that is provided for elite athletes may not take into account sport-related elements that make people more likely to have mental health issues or diagnostic or therapeutic issues that may be unique to this group. These factors include things like the fact that people who participate in sports are more likely to have problems with their mental health.…”

“…This kind of pessimism is known as defensive pessimism, and it arises when a person has pessimistic expectations about the course of future events. This leads the individual to make more efforts to protect themselves from possibly adverse consequences and to prepare more completely ( 31 ). According to research that is relevant to this issue, threat assessments may not necessarily be harmful to performance, but they could cause individuals to work harder on things that are simple or that they have mastered.…”

“…This is because anxious negotiators experience higher levels of physiological stress. These results are the result of the negotiator's having a low degree of self-efficacy, which is the cause of the problem ( 31 ). People who suffer from anxiety are less confident in their own ability to make sound decisions, so they look for guidance from outside sources and tend to place a greater amount of weight on that guidance, even if it is patently unsound.…”