Alcohol-associated hepatitis (AH) is a critical condition with high mortality rates and is worsened by infections. Organ failure is strongly associated with intestinal dysbiosis. Emerging research suggests that gut microbiota modulation with probiotics can improve AH outcomes. This study investigated the clinical and microbiome effects of high-dose probiotic infusion (HDPI) compared with corticosteroid therapy (CST) and fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT) in severe AH. Patients with biopsy-proven severe-AH were enrolled from March 2019 to June 2020 and matched for age and disease severity. The patients received HDPI (n = 20), FMT (n = 16), or CST (n = 14). HDPI consists of a potent probiotic mix delivered via a nasoduodenal tube for 6 days. The primary outcome was survival at 90-days. Stool samples were subjected to 16S and 18S rRNA sequencing to assess significant bacterial and fungal taxa and their interactions at baseline and post treatment. At 90-days, survival rates were 55%, 64.3%, and 87.5% (HDPI, CST, respectively). HDPI did not beneficially impact bacterial alpha-diversity but significantly altered beta-diversity. Notably, the number of pathogenic bacteria, such as Bilophila and Roseburia increased. Fungal analysis revealed no significant changes in alpha diversity, but significant dissimilarities in beta diversity post-HDPI. New fungal genera such as Basidiomycota and Phragmoplastophyta have emerged, with significant deleterious expansion in fungal communities and damaging modifications between fungal–bacterial interactions. HDPI failed to outperform CST in improving the clinical outcomes of patients with severe AH. While HDPI influenced both bacterial and fungal microbiomes, it also led to the persistence of pathogenic communities. FMT showed superior survival outcomes, highlighting the urgent need for further controlled trials.