The role of wage beliefs in the decision to become a nurse

Abstract

In light of skilled‐labor shortage, the effect of a change in the wage of nurses on their labor supply is intensely discussed in recent literature. Using extensive data of German 14‐ to 15‐year‐olds, I analyze the role of the beliefs about a nurse's wage in the decision to become one. To estimate a partial effect, I select controls and their functional form using post‐double‐selection, which is a data‐driven selection method based on regression shrinkage. Highlighting the importance of wages at the extensive margin of labor supply, the wage beliefs play a positive and statistically significant role. Although information is publicly available, educational choices knowingly suffer from misinformation. I find that especially those who do not become a nurse understate the wage. The results lead to two important policy implications. First, increasing the wage may help to overcome the shortage observed in many countries. Second, providing more information on the (relative) wage may be a successful strategy to attract more individuals into this profession. To assess the sensitivity of the results regarding omitted variable bias, I apply a novel approach. It turns out that potential unobserved confounders would have to be strong to overrule the conclusions.

The attractiveness of jobs in the German care sector: results of a factorial survey

“…The finding that income is an important but not a dominating job characteristic is in line with findings of further studies on nurses and midwives in Australia, public sector nurses in Malawi, nurses and midwives in Peru, doctors and nurses in China, and nurses in Thailand [ 23 , 29 , 34 – 36 ]. Wage and wage expectations have similarly been documented as relevant, though not dominating, determinants of whether or not students start vocational training in a nursing occupation [ 37 ]. The wage level is also a source of job satisfaction.…”

Nursing Before and after Covid-19: Outflows, Inflows and Self-Employment

“…They estimate a discrete labour supply model for the choice between different hours of work and between nursing and non-nursing occupations, where the latter appears to explain their higher elasticity of labour supply in nursing. For literature on nurses' labour supply more generally, see Andreassen et al (2017), Antonazzo et al (2003), Askildsen et al (2003), Di Tommaso et al (2009), Frijters et al (2007), Kankaanranta and Rissanen (2008), Kugler (2022) and Shields (2004).…”

Erwerbsverläufe und Einkommensentwicklung in der Pflege

“…So bedingen höhere Löhne ein höheres Arbeitsangebot von Pflegekräften (Antonazzo et al, 2003;Hanel et al, 2014), eine geringere Wahrscheinlichkeit, den Beruf verlassen zu wollen oder dies tatsächlich zu tun (Holmås, 2002;Frijters et al, 2007;Kankaanranta und Rissanen, 2008;Kroczek, 2021), eine höhere Attraktivität von Stellenanageboten in der Pflege (Doiron et al, 2014;Scott et al, 2015;Fields et al, 2018;Kroczek und Späth, 2022) und eine höhere allgemeine Arbeitszufriedenheit (Lu et al, 2005;Lu et al, 2012). Eine erst kürzlich veröffentlichte Studie von Kugler (2022) Bezogen auf diese Fragestellung findet sich eine deutliche Forschungslücke in der Literatur. So liegen, neben Studien zum Zusammenhang zwischen dem Lohn und der Attraktivität der Arbeit in der Pflege (siehe oben), einerseits Untersuchungen zur Lohnbildung auf diesem Teilarbeitsmarkt vor (Heyes, 2005;Elliott et al, 2007;Combes et al, 2015;Combes et al, 2018).…”