The scientific evolution of social justice leadership in education: structural and longitudinal analysis of the existing knowledge base, 2003–2022

Abstract

This study aims to delineate the intellectual and conceptual architecture of social justice leadership (SJL) research in education by reviewing the strategic themes that emerged during its scientific evolution. The study combines bibliometric performance and science mapping analysis of 135 articles on “SJL in education” retrieved from the Scopus database. SciMAT software (version 1.1.04) was used for the study since it allows for sequential analysis. Our analysis comprised three periods: Period 1 (2003–2012), Period 2 (2013–2017), and Period 3 (2018–2022). Studies during the first period mostly centered around transformative leadership, social justice, and equity themes, while the research focus during the second period moved toward the roles of principals in enabling justice. During the third period, the analysis revealed more variety in the themes addressed by scholars. Instructional leadership roles of principals and the outcomes of social justice leadership, such as equity and well-being for different groups vulnerable to injustices, were the most prominent themes addressed during the last period. The study’s findings enable us to reflect on this research field’s well-or underdeveloped aspects. They would help guide research interest into the under-investigated or emerging themes of SJL, which would eventually increase our understanding of the practice and outcomes of SJL in the educational context.

Global Research Trends of Digital Learning Media in Science Education: A Bibliometric Analysis

“…The results of this analysis can be used as a basis for developing inclusion and exclusion criteria in this bibliometric analysis. Inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria are used to determine the eligibility of articles, documents that are not appropriate will be excluded because they are considered outside the scope (Karakose et al, 2023). By doing so, we improved consistently the quality of research (Corsini et al, 2019).…”

A Bibliometric Analysis of the Literature on Mobile Learning Adoption and Continuance in the Field of Education

“…In this study, we used bibliometric analysis to identify core articles, authors, countries, institutions, and journals in the research area of mobile learning adoption and continuance in education. In addition, an evaluation of the existing 155 relevant articles obtained from the WoS database revealed knowledge flows and evolving research themes [58]. Although the study is limited by reliance on a single research database, it offers multiple conclusions for MACE research.…”

The Intellectual Evolution of Educational Leadership Research: A Combined Bibliometric and Thematic Analysis Using SciMAT

“…Previous research also called attention to the socio-economic status of students' families as a strong determinant of achievement gaps. This research provided evidence that principals' instructional leadership might help narrow the SES-based achievement gap by improving learning-related conditions in schools [138][139][140]. Shaked [133] suggested that principals' instructional leadership could eliminate injustices through school improvement 'because it strives rigorously to lead all students to high academic performance, regardless of diverse students' potentially marginalizing characteristics' (p.2).…”

“…Other subthemes associated with EDUCATIONAL-LEADERSHIP were Principal-Instructional-Leadership, School-Principalship, Democratic-Leadership, and Leadership-Preparation. A study by Karakose et al [138] found that research on social justice leadership increased significantly after 2018, and reached its peak in 2021. Researchers offered two explanations for increased interest in social justice leadership.…”