<b><i>Background:</i></b> In Dupuytren’s surgery, limited fasciectomy is still the gold-standard treatment. A relatively high risk of iatrogenic nerve injury has been observed especially when the spiral cords of the Dupuytren’s tissue pull digital nerves away from their normal anatomical location. Intraoperative neural marking could facilitate locating the potentially displaced nerves. Hence, surgery could be undertaken more quickly with a lower risk of iatrogenic nerve injury. <b><i>Objectives:</i></b> We hypothesize that digital nerves may be stained with methylene blue (MB) in vivo providing a visual aid to distinguish them from Dupuytren’s tissue. We aim to (a) test an in vivo nerve staining technique using MB in a rat sciatic nerve model and to (b) assess the safety of epineural MB injection. <b><i>Methods:</i></b> Three experiments were performed: first, the effects of (a) sham surgery, (b) epineural needle insertion, and (c) 40 μL epineural saline injection were tested in the rat sciatic nerve. Second, we determined the (a) histoanatomical localization of the epineurally injected 40 µL 1 m/m% MB stock solution and (b) we tested which saline dilution (i.e., 1:40, 1:80, and 1:160) of the stock solution does provide optimal blue color upon 40 µL epineural injection. Third, the functional and morphological effect of 40 µL 1:80 diluted MB injection was compared with that of saline, injected into the contralateral sciatic nerve. The functional effects were tested by assessing the pain threshold by using a dynamic plantar esthesiometer (DPA) and by examination of the animal’s gate and paw posture. Sciatic nerves were subjected to histological examination and morphometry to test structural damage. <b><i>Results:</i></b> Neither epineural needle insertion nor saline injection caused any functional or morphological changes. Histological examination revealed that the MB stained the epineural compartment. Epineural injection of 40 μL 1:80 diluted MB into the sciatic nerve stained an 18.18-mm segment of the nerve distal to the puncture point. DPA revealed unchanged pain threshold values on the plantar surface of the limbs. Normal gait and foot posture suggested normal motor functions in all groups. No histological changes were seen in the stained nerves, and the nerve fiber density remained unchanged. <b><i>Conclusion:</i></b> We demonstrated that in vivo nerve staining with MB is a suitable method to mark nerves without causing detectable negative effect to the stained nerve. Human trials are required to prove the efficacy of the technique in Dupuytren’s disease.