“…Despite this paper pointing out a gap in the research, I did not find any research papers addressing this problem of how teachers imparted knowledge. Instead there was a great deal of literature that focused on voice science and increasing pedagogical content knowledge in areas such as breath management (Cowley, 1999;Miller, 1986Miller, , 1993, phonation (Titze, 1995;Watts, Barnes-Burroughs, Etis, & Blanton, 2006;Westerman Gregg & Scherer, 2006), resonance and articulation (Kenny & Mitchell, 2006;Mürbe, Sundberg, Iwarsson, Pabst, & Hofmann, 1999;Oates, Bain, Davis, Chapman, & Kenny, 2006), registration, vocal health, control of voice ( Callaghan, 1997), acoustical measurements of good singing and what happens physiologically to achieve this (Oates, Bain, Davis, Chapman, & Kenny, 2006), ventricular fold abduction and differentiated movement in the vocal apparatus Kayes, 2004;Obert & Chicurel, 2005). challenged the dominant paradigm that exists that airflow is processed by vocal folds and then modified by pharynx, mouth and vocal cavities (Sundberg, Leanderson, von Euler, & Knutsson, 1991) Research carried out into motor skill acquisition and practice organization (Schmidt, 1975;Sherwood, 1996;Sherwood & Lee, 2003) is very useful for singing in that it gives insight into how people can acquire long term learning, which was an important aim of this study.…”