The Social Causes of Psychosis in North American Psychiatry: A Review of a Disappearing Literature

Abstract

Objective: To review the North American literature with respect to the role of social factors in the etiology of psychosis, including schizophrenia. Method: Relevant publications were identified through a search of MEDLINE from 1966 to 2006. Identified studies and articles had to originate in Canada or the United States to be included in the review. Articles written prior to 1966 were identified by cross-referencing bibliographies and reference lists. Articles were considered relevant if they discussed ethnoracial or other social factors as being causal or contributing to the development of psychosis or schizophrenia. Results: The relation between the etiology of psychosis and such social factors as poverty, migration, and racial discrimination has been neglected in the North American psychiatric literature for the last 40 years. In Canada and the United States, there is a dearth of research on these issues: the study of social causes of psychosis has been replaced by a focus on the clinical encounter, in which clinician bias is presumed to be responsible for widespread misdiagnosis of psychosis in minority (mainly African-American) populations. The reasons for neglecting social causes of psychosis in the North American psychiatric literature are obscure but may have to do with the rise of genetic-biological paradigms in recent decades. Conclusions: The neglect of social causes of psychosis in the North American psychiatric literature has been coincident with an increase in scholarly concern among European clinicians and researchers. Careful reading of the European literature may reveal helpful avenues for future investigation in the North American context. In addition, drawing on social science literature and methods may help to clarify mechanisms underlying poverty, migration, and racial discrimination that contribute to psychosis in vulnerable individuals and groups.

Common mental health problems in immigrants and refugees: general approach in primary care

“…35 Strong evidence shows that some groups of migrants have an elevated incidence of psychotic disorders after migration. [36][37][38][39] A recent meta-analysis found a mean weighted relative risk of schizophrenia among first-generation migrants of 2.7 (95% CI 2.3-3.2); even higher rates were found in the second generation. 40 Factors related to increased risk included coming from a developing country and an area where most of the population is black, suggesting that racism and discrimination have a role in elevated incidence.…”

A Reformulation of the Social Brain Theory for Schizophrenia: The Case for Out-Group Intolerance

“…The belief in the constant incidence/prevalence of schizophrenia has led to the belief that the sole causation of schizophrenia is genetic or neurodevelopmental, with very little role for environmental factors. In recent years there has been a growing interest in the social causation of schizophrenia which has led to a number of publications (see, e.g., Jarvis 2007;Selten andCantor-Graae 2005, 2007).…”

Schizophrenia—a parameters’ game?

“…Answers to this question range over a large scale, and are not always consistent. Some studies attribute schizophrenic symptoms solely to prenatal stress, or to social and other environmental factors during the patient's childhood and teenage years (Jarvis, 2007). On the other hand, genetic studies reveal a strong hereditary component of the illness (Bearden et al, 2007;Williams et al, 2007).…”