“…However, some of its premises are of dubious relevance in our research contexts, notably its assumptions that schooling and work are two distinct phases, and that it is possible therefore to calculate the ‘rates of return’ from education. This logic misrecognises how many young people in the Global South work from an early age, to support themselves, their families and their own schooling (Crossouard and Dunne, 2021; Crossouard et al, 2021; Dunne and Ananga, 2013; Okyere, 2012) and indeed are often required to do physical labour at school (Humphreys et al, 2015). The macro-economic focus of human capital theory and its uncritical framing of education as a closed ‘black box’ system (Resnik, 2006) cannot attend to the complex social dynamics of education, including their contributions to the reproduction of social inequalities (Bourdieu, 1984) and patriarchal gender relations (Crossouard and Dunne, 2021; Dunne, 2008; Dunne, et al, 2006).…”