The state of ethics education at medical schools in Turkey: taking stock and looking forward

Abstract

Background Ethics teaching is globally considered an essential part of medical education fostering professionalism. It does not only provide knowledge for good clinical conduct, but also trains medical students as virtuous practitioners. Although Turkey has had a considerable experience in ethics education of healthcare professionals, the general state of ethics curricula at medical schools in Turkey is unknown. Methods The purpose of this study was to collect comprehensive data about the ethics education programs at medical schools in Turkey. To this aim, we designed a cross-sectional descriptive questionnaire survey which focuses on the content, teaching years, teaching, assessment and evaluation methodologies, workforce and infrastructure. We delivered the questionnaire to all medical schools in Turkey. Seventy-nine medical schools participated in this study (response rate: 78%). Results Although most institutions had an undergraduate ethics curriculum (91.1%), the findings suggest deficiency of teaching personnel (34.2% had no instructors). Furthermore, the distribution and composition of the workforce was imbalanced. The content varies largely among institutions. Medical schools with an ethics department were more likely to diversify teaching topics. However, ethics education was largely based on the four-principle approach. The content was usually conveyed to students theoretically. Around 90% of schools had classroom lectures. It is the only method used at one-third of them. Clinical ethics education was mostly lacking. Multiple-choice tests were widely used to assess and evaluate student attainments (86.1%). Conclusions Staff qualified to teach ethics and ethics education integrated into the six-year medical curriculum given by a multidisciplinary team are urgent necessities. Considering teaching, assessment and evaluation methodologies used, most medical schools seem to fall short of fostering students to develop ethical attitudes. Endeavors aiming for modern topics should be encouraged. As the organization ethics education change continuously, we think that a platform for monitoring ethics education at medical schools in Turkey should be established. Such a body would help ethics instructors to network and find solutions to current problems and build shared wisdom.

Impact of a Novel Approach for Undergraduate Medical Ethics Education in The Middle East and South Asia

“…Several other medical ethics educators in the region also opine that the Anglo-European ethical traditions that shape contemporary medical ethics education are not su cient to encompass the indigenous values and beliefs of students in these regions [4,14,[49][50][51]. Other constraints that have been identi ed as hampering the integration of medical ethics into the curriculum include a lack of competent, dedicated medical ethics teachers and often indifferent institutional policies [2,[6][7][8][9].…”

“…It is re ected in the goals of formal curricula in almost all healthcare institutes and medical programs [3][4][5]. Achieving this goal has remained a complex task for educators around the World [6][7][8][9]. Additionally, the in uences of the socio-cultural environment of a region or country further add to the complexities of this discipline [4,10,11].…”

In Defense of Patient Autonomy in Kidney Failure Care When Treatment Choices Are Limited

“…Despite extensive academic discussion of the complexities of autonomy and empiric research exploring shared decision making in various clinical settings, [16][17][18] common clinician conceptions of autonomy and expectations regarding the requirements of respect for autonomy in clinical practice may be simplistic. Limited space or resources for exploring ethics in medical curricula, [19][20][21] for example, may encourage use of a checklist approach to ethics (Fig. 1) that provides little space for critical reflection or consideration of the complexities of applying particular concepts or principles in different settings.…”

The outcomes of a mobile just-in-time-learning intervention for teaching bioethics in Pakistan

“…In all situations, it is imperative to be respectful of patients and their wishes and make clinically sound and ethical decisions [ 1 ]. Bioethics is essential in the advocacy of the relationship between scientific practice and values essential to people’s life and society, and teaching bioethics enables students to understand the conflicting areas and develop decision-making skills based on moral and ethical principles [ 2 , 3 ]. There is no resource for identifying the best option in real-time ethical decision-making.…”