Despite recent experiments showing that BrdUrd-induced mutagenesis can be independent of the level of bromouracil (BrUra) 5-Bromouracil (BrUra), an analogue of thymine, and 2-aminopurine (APur), an analogue of adenine, cause transition mutations in various organisms (1-14). A-T--'G-C and G-C oA-T transitions are induced by both base analogues; however, the extent of their bidirectionality remains unclear (8-21). It is known that BrUra and APur are incorporated "normally" into DNA opposite adenine and thymine, respectively. Ambiguities in their base pairing properties (BrUra can pair with guanine and APur with cytosine) are clearly important determinants in their mutagenicity and lead to what Freese (9) and Rudner (19) defined as replication errors and incorporation errors.Under certain conditions, BrUra substitution in DNA is not correlated with BrdUrd mutagenesis. This point was forcefully made in recent experiments by Kaufman and Davidson (22) using Syrian hamster melanoma cells and by Aebersold using Chinese hamster cells (1). For example, in the Kaufman and Davidson experiment it was shown that BrdUrd-induced mutation frequencies in a Syrian hamster melanoma cell line depended not on how much BrUra was stably substituted for thymine in the DNA but rather on the concentration of BrdUrd in the cell growth medium. In view of the evidence in Salmonella (14) and in bacteriophage T4 (23), which supports the idea that BrUra increases replication errors when acting in a template capacity, the Syrian hamster melanoma results are remarkable, to say the least.The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U. S. C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact.
1801It will be of fundamental importance in understanding the mechanism of BrdUrd mutagenesis to recognize that the uncoupling of the level of BrUra substitution in DNA from the level of BrdUrd mutagenesis was achieved through the addition of deoxythymidine or deoxycytidine to the BrdUrd mutagenesis medium (1, 2, 22). The addition of deoxythymidine resulted in less, or even undetectable, BrUra substitution in DNA but the same, or increased, level of mutagenesis (1, 2, 22). Conversely, the addition of deoxycytidine with BrdUrd during mutagenesis resulted in a complete inhibition of mutagenesis but full substitution of BrUra for thymine in DNA (2).These observations have led some investigators to conclude that BrdUrd mutagenesis occurs because of an altered physiological state such as."deoxycytidinelessness" (24) or to implicate BrdUrd metabolites as allosteric effectors of the fidelity of DNA synthetic enzymes (1). It has also been proposed that BrdUrd mutagenesis does not involve mispairing of BrUra during DNA synthesis (5, 10, 22, 25).The conclusion that BrUra base pairs exactly as thymine conflicts with certain experiments termed "clean growth" (23) in which BrUra-substituted DNA was proved to induce replication errors in the absence of exogeno...