Adolescent cancer survivors face psychological effects that can include isolation, poor peer relations, anxiety, depression, and fear of recurrence, which can increase their risk for psychological late effects and poor health posttreatment. The purpose of this exploratory analysis was to understand the experiences of adolescent cancer survivors, with a particular focus on identity, health promotion, and meaning making. In-depth interviews were conducted with 12 adolescent cancer survivors. Constant comparative analysis was used to identify core themes from the data. Findings revealed that adolescent survivors might experience an identity paradox when making the transition to "survivor," which can contribute to their sense of isolation and risk of health-detracting behaviors. Health promotion, prevention, and supportive programs need to be developed for health care professionals to address the isolation and identity transition needs of adolescent cancer survivors.