The strength of association between psychological factors and clinical outcome in tendinopathy: A systematic review

Abstract

Objective Tendinopathy is often a disabling, and persistent musculoskeletal disorder. Psychological factors appear to play a role in the perpetuation of symptoms and influence recovery in musculoskeletal pain. To date, the impact of psychological factors on clinical outcome in tendinopathy remains unclear. Therefore, the purpose of this systematic review was to investigate the strength of association between psychological factors and clinical outcome in tendinopathy. Methods A systematic review of the literature and qualitative synthesis of published trials was conducted. Electronic searches of ovid MEDLINE, ovid EMBASE, PsychINFO, CINAHL and Cochrane Library was undertaken from their inception to June 2020. Eligibility criteria included RCT’s and studies of observational design incorporating measurements of psychological factors and pain, disability and physical functional outcomes in people with tendinopathy. Risk of Bias was assessed by two authors using a modified version of the Newcastle Ottawa Scale. High or low certainty evidence was examined using the GRADE criteria. Results Ten studies of observational design (6-cross sectional and 4 prospective studies), involving a sample of 719 participants with tendinopathy were included. Risk of bias for the included studies ranged from 12/21 to 21/21. Cross-sectional studies of low to very low level of certainty evidence revealed significant weak to moderate strength of association (r = 0.24 to 0.53) between psychological factors and clinical outcomes. Prospective baseline data of very low certainty evidence showed weak strength of association between psychological factors and clinical outcome. However, prospective studies were inconsistent in showing a predictive relationship between baseline psychological factors on long-term outcome. Cross sectional studies report similar strengths of association between psychological factors and clinical outcomes in tendinopathy to those found in other musculoskeletal conditions. Conclusion The overall body of the evidence after applying the GRADE criteria was low to very low certainty evidence, due to risk of bias, imprecision and indirectness found across included studies. Future, high quality longitudinal cohort studies are required to investigate the predictive value of baseline psychological factors on long-term clinical outcome.

Psychological factors associated with foot and ankle pain: a mixed methods systematic review

“…The review concluded a weak to moderate strength of association between psychological factors and pain, disability and physical functional outcome in tendinopathy from 10 observational studies. Longitudinal data failed to show a predictive relationship between baseline psychological factors and long-term outcomes [ 14 ]. Although these findings are of interest, the review needs to be considered in light of some limitations.…”

Psychosocial and individual factors affecting Quality of Life (QoL) in patients suffering from Achilles tendinopathy: a systematic review

“…This feeling of hopelessness can moderately or intensely reduce their ability to perform daily tasks. Some studies suggest that factors such as fear and self-efficacy are relevant for tendinopathy [19,47].…”

Biopsychosocial approach to tendinopathy

“…Indeed, a patient's level of self-efficacy may be a stronger predictor of non-surgical outcomes than the structural defects that exist in imaging. 29 30 Dunn et al found a modest association between physiological issues and the clinical outcome in tendinopathy but acknowledged the need for more longitudinal studies to investigate the sway of psychosocial issues on clinical outcome. 29 This is also voiced by Mc Auliffe et al, who accept that although this future research may not affect clinical outcomes, it would give greater clarity on how these psychological factors can influence prognosis and pain modulation in patients.…”