Threose nucleic acid (TNA) is an artificial genetic polymer capable of heredity and evolution that is studied in the context of RNA chemical etiology. Its simplified four-carbon threose backbone replaces the five-carbon ribose in natural nucleic acids. Nonetheless, TNA forms stable antiparallel Watson-Crick homoduplexes and heteroduplexes with complimentary DNA and RNA. TNA base pairs with RNA more favorably than DNA, but the reason is unknown. Here, we employ NMR, ITC, UV and CD studies to probe the structural and dynamic properties of RNA/TNA and DNA/TNA heteroduplexes that give rise to the differential stability. The results indicate that TNA templates the structure of heteroduplexes, forcing an A-like helical geometry. Further NMR measurements of kinetic and thermodynamic parameters for individual base pair opening events reveal unexpected asymmetric breathing fluctuations of the DNA/TNA helix, which are also manifested at the molecular level. These results suggest that DNA is unable to fully adapt to the conformational constraints of the rigid TNA backbone and that nucleic acid breathing dynamics are determined from both backbone and base contributions.