The Structure of Negative Social Ties in Rural Village Networks

Abstract

Negative (antagonistic) connections have been of longstanding theoretical importance for social structure. In a population of 24,696 adults interacting face to face within 176 isolated villages in western Honduras, we measured all connections that were present, amounting to 105,175 positive and 16,448 negative ties. Here, we show that negative and positive ties exhibit many of the same structural characteristics. We then develop a complete taxonomy of all 138 possible triads of two-type relationships. Consistent with balance theory, we find that antagonists of friends and friends of antagonists tend to be antagonists; but, in an important empirical refutation of balance theory, we find that antagonists of antagonists also tend to be antagonists, not friends. Finally, villages with comparable levels of animosity tend to be geographically proximate. Similar processes, involving social contact, give rise to both positive and negative social ties in rural villages, and negative ties play an important role in social structure.

Coalitions and conflict: A longitudinal analysis of men's politics

“…Minimal network reciprocity in conflict nominations, within timewaves, is consistent with other studies, where negative ties tend to be reciprocated less than positive ties, e.g. 34 vs. 5% in rural Honduran villages (Isakov et al, 2019), and 60-80 vs. 10-20% in a massively multiplayer online game (Szell et al, 2010).…”

“…Transitivity in coalition formation is not unique to humans. For example, proximity networks in a community of bottlenose dolphin have been shown to be similarly patterned by transitivity (Christakis, 2019;Lusseau, 2003). Why transitivity structures coalition formation may be due to lower transaction costs when building a relationship with an ally's ally, greater probability of shared interests when allying with an ally's ally or greater coalitional synergy.…”

Breaking the barriers of animosity: innovation in business models as a positioning strategy

“…Throughout the history of humanity, various economic, political, religious and cultural conflicts between different societies have been documented; in this way, antagonism in human beings is a very ancient and deeply studied topic in classical ethnographies, which have highlighted the importance of antagonistic interactions between different groups and between their individuals ( Isakov et al., 2019 ).…”

Triadic embeddedness structure in family networks predicts mobile communication response to a sudden natural disaster

“…4 , Supplementary Figs. 13 – 14 , and Supplementary Table 25 ), which contravene the principles of structural balance theory and transitivity 26 , 39 – 42 . One possible explanation is that embeddedness allows relatively unconnected family members to be indirectly connected.…”