The Struggle for Recognition: A Study of the Existence of the Indonesian Ahmadiyya Community in the Concept of Axel Honneth's Recognition

Ahmad, Mubarak Hussaini; Bunyamin, Bunyamin; Nawawi, Muhammad Azhar; Pratama, Cahya Adhitya; Junior, Rizkindo

doi:10.37680/muharrik.v5i2.1648

Cited by 3 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 8 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…The Indonesian Ahmadiyya Congregation (Jemaah Ahmadiyah Indonesia/JAI) has struggled to gain recognition from the community, such as social programs and the legality of the law. However, JAI remains the target of intolerant groups to carry out persecution because the teachings adhered to by JAI are considered heretical due to different Islamic concepts in general (M. Ahmad et al, 2022). Various studies reveal various acts of violence experienced by Ahmadiyah, such as the destruction of houses of worship, physical attacks, and restrictions on rights in religion and politics (Sulistyati, 2020;Andi Muh.…”

Section: Violence Against Ahmadiyya As Productive Intolerancementioning

confidence: 99%

Violence Against Ahmadiyya as Productive Intolerance: Adressing Jeremy Menchik’s Godly Nationalism

Rizkita,

Riyanto

2023

Fuaduna

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This article examines godly nationalism using the theory of secularism. This connection is based on a shared "we-feeling" rooted in the common belief systems fostered by cooperation between the state and religious organizations (NU, Muhammadiyah, Persis). Jeremy Menchik argues that violence against Ahmadiyya should be viewed as "productive intolerance" rather than merely damaging democracy, as it is intended to protect this religious bond. The concept of godly nationalism has been criticized for neglecting religious freedom as a human right. This concept also overemphasizes macro-level data while failing to explain the local realities experienced by Ahmadiyya. The primary data for this research is Menchik's book titled "Islam and Democracy in Indonesia: Tolerance Without Liberalism,” then, it will be analyzed theoretically by borrowing Jose Casanova's secularism theory. This article found that the absence of secularism discourse throughout his work influenced his stance in understanding the nuances of religious intolerance in Indonesia. According to Menchik, Indonesia is viewed as a moderate country, but not in the form of binary opposition, as seen in the genealogy of secularism in the Western world, where religion is often positioned with certain negative prepositions.

show abstract

Section: Violence Against Ahmadiyya As Productive Intolerancementioning

confidence: 99%

Violence Against Ahmadiyya as Productive Intolerance: Adressing Jeremy Menchik’s Godly Nationalism

Rizkita,

Riyanto

2023

Fuaduna

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Penelitian lainnya telah mengkaji persoalan pengaruh dan penyebaran gerakan Ahmadiyah dalam kehidupan masyarakat di negara-negara timur dan barat (Galib et al, 2022;Iryanto, 2023;Sari, 2012). Penelitian lainnya juga banyak diarahkan pada aspek minoritisasi dan kontroversi terhadap gerakan Ahmadiyyah (M. Ahmad et al, 2022;Mudzakkir, 2017;Rahim, 2014). Penelitian ini berbeda dengan beberapa kajian terdahulu yang disebutkan, namun sedikit dekat dengan apa yang sudah dikaji oleh Dimansa (2022) yang mengkaji ajaran dan perkembangan Ahmadiyah (Dimansa, 2022).…”

unclassified

Ahmadiyah: Analisis Terhadap Teologi dan Perkembangan

Tarhan,

Abdullah

2024

ALWATZIKHOEBILLAH

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Ahmadiyya is a phenomenon of renewal of Islamic thought in India with theological characteristics that include it. This article aims to explore the theological concepts proposed by the Ahmadiyya and trace their development. This analysis was carried out through a literature study with a social perspective approach. Based on this study, it can be concluded that the emergence of Ahmadiyya was the result of the thoughts of figures who tried to actualize religious teachings through social understanding and context. This research also shows that Ahmadiyya is a sect in Islam that emerged as a response to the challenges and socio-religious dynamics of its time.

show abstract

“…Oleh karena itu, penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui komodifikasi konten kehidupan pribadi selebritas di media televisi pada era digital, dengan menggunakan konsep struggle for recognition. Dalam penelitian sebelumnya, konsep ini digunakan untuk menjelaskan perjuangan eksistensi mazhab keagamaan di tengah upaya puritanisasi (Ahmad et al 2022) dan hak-hak pengendara sepeda dalam menghadapi regulasi transportasi umum (Egan 2021). Sedangkan dalam konsep struggle for recognition (cinta (love), tatanan hukum (legal order), dan solidaritas (solidarity) (Marta 2018)) dalam penelitian ini berfokus pada upaya meraih popularitas, yakni eksistensi yang berujung pada kepentingan ekonomi di era digital.…”

unclassified

Popularitas Dan Komodifikasi Konten Televisi Di Era Digital

Aditianingrum,

Adnan

2023

Jurnal Analisa Sosiologi

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Television often commodifies content in nowadays’ digital era, especially those related to the personal life of celebrities. In fact, this violates the norms stated in the provisions of P3SPS Chapter 9th article 13th paragraph 2nd regarding Respect for Privacy Rights and has the potential to make audiences ignore social realities that exist in society. This study uses a qualitative descriptive approach which aims to show the commodification of the personal life content of artists on television in the digital era by using the concept of struggle for recognition and institutions from market from meaning. Through literature review by collecting observational data on television and YouTube content with the theme of the artist's personal life, as well as secondary data in the form of online news searches, documents and journals to complement the findings. The results of the study show that the greater the ability of each actor to become a prosumer and reach the popularity, the greater the opportunity to commodify personal content facilitated by the broadcasting industry and other institutions for economic purposes. This can be seen in various television stations which commodify the content of the personal lives of artists by showing wedding processions, 7 monthly processions, and aqiqah with quite high intensity in 2021, as well as other artists' daily activities in infotainment by combining content from the artist's Youtube channel. This phenomenon shifts existing values which makes the KPI institution soften in responding to it. Keywords: Broadcast Industry, Commodification, Digital, Prosumer <h2>Abstrak</h2>Televisi kerap melakukan komodifikasi konten di era digital saat ini, terlebih yang berkaitan dengan kehidupan pribadi. Padahal, hal ini melanggar norma yang tercantum dalam ketentuan P3SPS Bab 9 pasal 13 ayat 2 mengenai Penghormatan Terhadap Hak Privasi dan berpotensi membuat khalayak mengabaikan realitas sosial yang ada di masyarakat. Penelitian ini menggunakan pendekatan deskriptif kualitatif yang bertujuan menunjukkan komodifikasi konten kehidupan pribadi artis dalam televisi di era digital dengan menggunakan konsep struggle for recognition dan institusi dari market from meaning. Melalui kajian kepustakaan dengan pengumpulan data observasi konten televisi dan Youtube yang bertema kehidupan pribadi artis, serta data sekunder berupa penelusuran berita daring, dokumen, dan jurnal untuk melengkapi temuan. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa semakin besar kemampuan setiap aktor untuk menjadi prosumer dan mendulang popularitas, semakin besar pula peluang untuk mengkomodifikasikan konten pribadi yang difasilitasi oleh industri penyiaran beserta institusi lainnya dengan tujuan ekonomi. Hal ini tampak pada berbagai stasiun televisi yang mengkomodifikasikan konten kehidupan pribadi para artis dengan menayangkan prosesi pernikahan, prosesi 7 bulanan, serta aqiqah dengan intensitas cukup tinggi di tahun 2021, juga aktivitas harian artis lainnya di infotainment dengan menggabungkan konten dari channel Youtube artis. Fenomena ini menggeser nilai yang ada yang membuat melunaknya institusi KPI dalam menyikapinya. Kata Kunci: Industri Penyiaran, Komodifikasi, Digitali, Prosumer

show abstract

The Struggle for Recognition: A Study of the Existence of the Indonesian Ahmadiyya Community in the Concept of Axel Honneth's Recognition

Cited by 3 publications

References 8 publications

Violence Against Ahmadiyya as Productive Intolerance: Adressing Jeremy Menchik’s Godly Nationalism

Violence Against Ahmadiyya as Productive Intolerance: Adressing Jeremy Menchik’s Godly Nationalism

Ahmadiyah: Analisis Terhadap Teologi dan Perkembangan

Popularitas Dan Komodifikasi Konten Televisi Di Era Digital

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About