The study protocol of a cluster-randomised controlled trial of family-mediated personalised activities for nursing home residents with dementia

Abstract

BackgroundFollowing admission to a nursing home, the feelings of depression and burden that family carers may experience do not necessarily diminish. Additionally, they may experience feelings of guilt and grief for the loss of a previously close relationship. At the same time, individuals with dementia may develop symptoms of depression and agitation (BPSD) that may be related to changes in family relationships, social interaction and stimulation. Until now, interventions to alleviate carer stress and BPSD have treated carers and relatives separately rather than focusing on maintaining or enhancing their relationships. One-to-one structured activities have been shown to reduce BPSD and also improve the caring experience, but barriers such as a lack of resources impede the implementation of activities in aged care facilities. The current study will investigate the effect of individualised activities based on the Montessori methodology administered by family carers in residential care.Methods/DesignWe will conduct a cluster-randomised trial to train family carers in conducting personalised one-to-one activities based on the Montessori methodology with their relatives. Montessori activities derive from the principles espoused by Maria Montessori and subsequent educational theorists to promote engagement in learning, namely task breakdown, guided repetition, progression in difficulty from simple to complex, and the careful matching of demands to levels of competence. Persons with dementia living in aged care facilities and frequently visiting family carers will be included in the study. Consented, willing participants will be randomly assigned by facility to a treatment condition using the Montessori approach or a control waiting list condition. We hypothesise that family carers conducting Montessori-based activities will experience improvements in quality of visits and overall relationship with the resident as well as higher self-rated mastery, fewer depressive symptoms, and a better quality of life than carers in the waiting list condition.DiscussionWe hypothesise that training family carers to deliver personalised activities to their relatives in a residential setting will make visits more satisfying and may consequently improve the quality of life for carers and their relatives. These beneficial effects might also reduce nursing staff burden and thus impact positively on residential facilities.Trial RegistrationAustralian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry - ACTRN12611000998943

Family Involvement in Nursing Homes: Are Family Caregivers Getting What They Want?

“…Other research has explored how to enhance cooperation between staff and families (Hertzberg & Ekman, 2000), provide support for decisional conflict among family caregivers who have placed an individual (Chang, Schneider, & Sessanna, 2011), improve the interaction families have with the resident when they do visit (Gaugler, 2005; van der Ploeg, Camp, Eppingstall, Runci, & O’Connor, 2012), and measure staff attitudes about staff–family relationships (Bauer, Fetherstonhaugh, & Lewis, 2012a, 2012b). However, research to date has not asked families what types of involvement they prefer and whether the facilities provide for them.…”

“…The provision of person-centered or individualized care to institutionalized seniors with dementia is widely considered a hallmark of best care practice (Suhonen, Välimäki, & Katajisto, 2000;R. T. Woods, 2001).…”

Measuring the impact of caregiving on informal carers: a construct validation study of the CarerQol instrument

“…The focus in this paper is on the CarerQol (see Figure 1 ). This instrument was developed in 2006, in a similar way as the EuroQol instrument [ 38 ], and it has been applied in several studies since [ 26 , 39 - 45 ].…”

A cluster-randomized crossover trial of Montessori activities delivered by family carers to nursing home residents with behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia

“…In addition to input from volunteers, family members also often wish to be involved in the continued care of their relative despite admission to a nursing home. Their visits to family members with severe dementia and BPSD may however be stressful, with the quality of visits affected by the care recipient's BPSD (van der Ploeg et al, 2012a). Activity programs underpinned by the Montessori method can provide an opportunity for family members to contribute positively to both residents' and families' well-being during their visits.…”