The subversive potential of Leo Tolstoy’s ‘defamiliarisation’: a case study in drawing on the imagination to denounce violence

Abstract

In his later years, Leo Tolstoy wrote numerous books, essays and pamphlets expounding his newly-articulated denunciations of all political violence, whether by dissidents or ostensibly legitimate states. If these writings have inspired many later pacifists and anarchists, it is partly thanks to his masterful deployment of the literary technique of 'defamiliarisation'-or looking at the familiar as if new-to shake readers into recognising the absurdity of common justifications of violence, admitting their implicit complicity in it, and noticing the process which numbed them into accepting such complicity. This paper discusses Tolstoy's use of the imagination to defamiliarise and denounce violence, first by citing a number of typical examples, then by reflecting on four of its subversive characteristics: its disruption of automated perception, its implicit concession of some recognition, its corrosion of conventional respect for traditional hierarchies, and its encouragement of empathy.

Pacifism and Nonviolence: Discerning the Contours of an Emerging Multidisciplinary Research Agenda

“…How should the aesthetics of pacifism and nonviolence be analysed? (Antliff, 2020;Carter et al, 2013;Christoyannopoulos, 2019;Darweish and Rigby, 2015;Jahanbegloo, 2013;Laursen, 2020;Thaler and Mihai, 2020;Zunes, 1994Zunes, , 1999 Five, there is scope to study the multiple (political, social, economic, psychological, cultural, philosophical, etc) direct and indirect consequences of violence and militarism, and of nonviolent action and pacifism. What are these multiple consequences of violence and militarism (including standing armies and more generally permanent military preparedness), and how do case studies and empirical analysis help understand these?…”

Nomadic Identities in Marina Carr’s By the Bog of Cats… and Anna Karenina

“…Defamiliarisation is defined by Alexandre Christoyannopoulos (2019) as "looking at the familiar as if newto shake readers into recognising the absurdity of common justifications of violence, admitting their implicit complicity in it, and noticing the process which numbed them into accepting such complicity" (562). This term is used in this research paper in context of Marina Carr"s protagonists" nomadic identities as familiar yet unrecognized under the constraints of social oppression and marital constraints/motherhood.…”

Reconciliation through Estrangement

“…38 Thus deployed, estrangement is sparked by a stubborn refusal to take settled meanings and conventional understandings for granted. 39 Estrangement as an artistic device has had an astonishing career. Looking back at his own conceptual innovation fifty years later, Shklovsky noted with amazement how far the idea had traveled.…”