Background/Objectives: This systematic review seeks to assess the effectiveness of different orthodontic and combined orthodontic–surgical approaches for correcting gummy smile, with a focus on treatment efficacy, duration, and the potential for integrating various techniques. The objective is to offer evidence-based recommendations for the optimal management of gummy smile. Methods: A thorough search of the literature was conducted in the PubMed, Cochrane Library, Scopus, and Web of Science databases, covering publications from 1 January 1982 to 4 November 2024. Only randomized controlled trials involving adult human subjects with available full-text articles were included, while systematic reviews, editorials, case reports, and studies involving animals or in vitro experiments were excluded. Studies were selected based on their relevance to orthodontic or combined orthodontic–surgical treatments for correcting excessive gingival display (gummy smile), particularly in cases where residual growth does not impact treatment outcomes. The primary focus was on evaluating the efficacy of these interventions in improving smile aesthetics. Follow-up data were considered when available, though not required for inclusion. Results: The findings revealed that both orthodontic and surgical methods are effective in reducing gingival display. Orthognathic surgery offers lasting outcomes, particularly for patients with vertical maxillary excess, whereas orthodontic treatments, including the use of skeletal anchorage devices, are particularly effective for less severe cases. Minimally invasive approaches, such as botulinum toxin injections, provided temporary but promising results for patients reluctant to undergo surgery. Conclusions: Orthodontic and surgical techniques are viable options for treating gummy smile, with treatment choices depending on the condition’s severity. Future research, particularly long-term randomized studies, is required to further refine treatment protocols and improve patient outcomes.
