Objective-This study compared patients with schizophrenia whose antipsychotic medications were switched to manage treatment-resistant positive psychotic symptoms with those for whom another antipsychotic was added. Psychiatrists' characteristics and perceptions of effectiveness of the medication change on clinical outcomes were also reported.Methods-Psychiatrists participating in a nationally representative mailed survey (N=209) reported on the clinical features, management, and response to the change in antipsychotic medication (added versus switched) of one adult patient with treatment-refractory schizophrenia under their care for at least one year.Results-Thirty-three percent of patients were treated with an added antipsychotic medication. Compared with patients whose antipsychotic medications were switched, those with an added antipsychotic medication were more likely to be female, to have received care from the same psychiatrist for more than two years, and to have been recently prescribed an antidepressant. Compared with psychiatrists who switched antipsychotic prescriptions, those who added an antipsychotic reported that the change was less likely to reduce positive symptoms, improve functioning, and prevent hospitalization. Psychiatrists who added rather than switched antipsychotics reported more frequent attendance at educational programs sponsored by a pharmaceutical company.
Conclusions-Consistent
NIH-PA Author ManuscriptNIH-PA Author Manuscript NIH-PA Author Manuscript treatment-resistant positive psychotic symptoms. In light of these findings, efforts to identify and implement more effective evidence-based pharmacologic approaches should be undertaken.A substantial proportion of patients with schizophrenia, estimated at 10% to 30% of outpatients, are considered resistant to standard antipsychotic treatment (1-3). In an inpatient population of one state psychiatric hospital, roughly one-half of patients with schizophrenia were determined to be treatment resistant on the basis of inadequate response to two different antipsychotic medication trials of at least six weeks' duration (4). Treatment-resistant patients often exhibit persistent residual disability and impaired quality of life and incur significant health care costs despite sustained adherence with antipsychotic medications (2).Clozapine is the only antipsychotic medication with demonstrated efficacy for treating positive symptoms in treatment-resistant schizophrenia (1,5,6). However, despite dissemination of evidence-based treatment guidelines for schizophrenia that strongly endorse the use of clozapine (7-9), the extent of its use in the United States remains well below the estimated prevalence of treatment-resistant schizophrenia (10,11).Clinicians faced with a patient who does not respond to or cannot tolerate standard antipsychotic therapy are left with few treatment options. One option is to switch the patient to another antipsychotic agent in hopes that its receptor profile will prove beneficial (12-14). However, a considerable...