The time between intention and action affects the experience of action

Abstract

We present a study investigating how the delay between the intention to act and the following action, influenced the experience of action. In experiments investigating sense of agency and experience of action, the contrast is most often between voluntary and involuntary actions. It is rarely asked whether different types of intentions influence the experience of action differently. To investigate this we distinguished between proximal intentions (i.e., intentions for immediate actions) and delayed intentions (i.e., intentions with a temporal delay between intention and action). The distinction was implemented in an intentional binding paradigm, by varying the delay between the time where participants formed the intention to act and the time at which they performed the action. The results showed that delayed intentions were followed by a stronger binding effect for the tone following the action compared to proximal intentions. The actions were reported to have occurred earlier for delayed intentions than for proximal intentions. This effect was independent of the binding effect usually found in intentional binding experiments. This suggests that two perceptual shifts occurred in the contrast between delayed intentions and proximal intentions: The first being the binding effect, the second a general shift in the perceived time of action. Neither the stronger binding effect for tone, nor the earlier reports of action, differed across delays for delayed intentions. The results imply that delayed intentions and proximal intentions have a different impact on the experience of action.

Action-outcome delays modulate the temporal expansion of intended outcomes

“…While our experimental design did not directly assess this aspect, recent research suggests that intentional operationalisation through experimental design could influence the binding effect 84 , 85 . Philosophical literature on the phenomenology of intention 86 discusses a distinction between proximal and distal intentions.…”

Social media fashion influencer eWOM communications: understanding the trajectory of sustainable fashion conversations on YouTube fashion haul videos

“…The rise in sustainable fashion keywords may correlate with real-world events, such as the Rana Plaza factory collapse . Existing research suggests that societal action typically lags behind awareness (Vinding et al , 2015). This may explain the delay in the increase of sustainable fashion comments (i.e.…”

Effects of Vibration-Based Generation of Timing of Tactile Perception on Upper Limb Function After Stroke: A Case Study

“…The 9-HPT was used for this task, in which the goal was to remove all nine pegs and place them on a plate. This goal was used as a cognitive cue [44], suggesting that even without sensory function improvement, setting and achieving the goal may have contributed to an increased sense of agency.…”