The well-known mechanisms of interaction between precipitates and dislocations are shearing (for shearable precipitates) and bypassing mechanisms (for nonshearable precipitates). The transition from shearable to nonshearable precipitates in precipitation hardening alloys leads to changes of dislocation motion mode and dislocation multiplication behavior, which inevitably causes different PLC behaviors.In this study, we systematically investigate the influence of shearable and nonshearable Al3(Sc, Zr) precipitates on PLC behaviors by experimental characterization for precipitation hardening AlMgScZr alloys. We analyze the onset strain, critical strain-rate range, serration amplitude, and propagation behavior of PLC bands in detail for AlMgScZr alloys with shearable and nonshearable precipitates, respectively. We find that the transition from shearable to nonshearable precipitates changes the PLC band propagation behavior, decreases the magnitude of serration amplitude, expands the strain-rate range as well as decreases the critical strain rate between normal behavior (the critical strain increases with the increase of strain rate) and inverse behavior (the critical strain decreases with the increase of strain rate) regimes due to the different dislocation-precipitate interactions. Besides, the transition from shearable to nonshearable precipitates increases the onset strain at normal behavior while decreases the onset strain at inverse behavior depending on the different roles of precipitates in the solute-dislocation interaction. Finally, we reveal the nature of influence of different dislocation-precipitate interactions on PLC behavior considering different strengthening mechanisms based on quantitative characterization on precipitates and dislocation density.