The herbicidal action of diquat dibromide (DD) on plant cells is due primarily to the initiation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation, lipoperoxidation, and apoptotic cell death. It has been demonstrated that oxidative stress also occurs in animal cells exposed to high concentrations of DD; however, observations of DD’s effects on animal cells at concentrations below the reported ROS-initiation threshold suggest that some of these effects may not be attributable to ROS-induced cell death. Our results suggest that DD causes disruption of the Wnt pathway, calcium dysregulation, and cytoskeletal damage during development. Using embryos of the pond snail Lymnaea palustris as our model organism, we observed increased mortality, developmental delay and abnormality, altered motility, calcium dysregulation, decreased heart rate, and arrhythmia in embryos exposed to DD. Sperm extracted from adult snails that were exposed to DD exhibit altered motility, increased abundance, and high mortality. Effects were quantified via real-time imaging, heart rate assessment, flow cytometry, and mortality scoring. We propose that there are two models for the mechanism of DD’s action in animal cells: at low concentrations (≤28 µg/L), apoptotic cell death does not occur, but cytoskeletal elements, calcium regulation, and Wnt signaling are compromised, causing irreversible damage in L. palustris embryos; such damage is partially remediated with antioxidants or lithium chloride. At high concentrations of DD (≥44.4 µg/L), calcium dysregulation may be triggered, leading to the establishment of an intracellular positive feedback loop of ROS formation in the mitochondria, calcium release from the endoplasmic reticulum, calcium efflux, and apoptotic cell death. Permanent cellular damage occurring from exposure to sublethal concentrations of this widespread herbicide underscores the importance of research that elucidates the mechanism of DD on nontarget organisms.