The Treatment of Relationship Status in Research on Dating and Mate Selection

Abstract

The relationship status of study participants (e.g., daters, cohabitors, marrieds, or unmarrieds) has implications for understanding dating and mate selection. Procedures used in studies may blur or ignore status distinctions. The authors examined methods used in 791 studies published from 1991 – 2001. Most commonly, status of participants is unspecified, and different statuses are collapsed for analysis. Status of participants is associated with recruitment method, and type (e.g., romantic, friendship) and form (e.g., perceived, current) of relationship measured. Unspecified samples are associated with research on the topics of universal properties or causal conditions, and specified samples with mate selection. The connection between status and topic is becoming more blurred over time. Recommendations for studying and reporting status are provided.

Conflict Strategies and Intimacy: Variations by Romantic Relationship Development and Gender

“…Similarly, a review of articles published in the 1990's found that relationship status was not assessed or was collapsed in most samples suggesting that behaviors and affective states do not change over the development of a relationship (Surra, Boettcher-Burke, Cottle, West, & Gray, 2007). As concluded by the authors of the review, we believe that relationship development does play a role in the behaviors and emotions displayed in a romantic relationship.…”

Not truly partnerless: Non-residential partnerships and retreat from marriage in Spain

“…Previous studies have shown that non-residential partnerships are quite common in societies with a late pattern of marriage and low prevalence of cohabitation, such as Japan (Rallu andKojima 2000, Iwasawa 2004). Living-apart-together among young adults may be more relevant than ever, as individuals spend more of their lifetimes dating and selecting mates than previously (Surra et al 2007) and, once they find a suitable partner, they feel little social and family pressure to "settle down" together in a common dwelling. We will try to elucidate whether the high prevalence of non-residential partnerships among young adults is linked to economic constraints (e.g.…”

Dating is Hard Work: A Narrative Approach to Understanding Sexual and Romantic Relationships in Young Adulthood

“…A previous study about relationship status recommended that future research clarify relationship language, because language is always evolving (Surra et al 2007).…”