Reversible binding of the tetrahedral oxoanions MoO 42-and WO 4 2-to two carboxylato ligands of the soluble scavenger protein WtpA from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus enforces a quasi-octahedral MO 6 coordination in which the +VI oxidation state is destabilized.The 4d and 5d group-VI elements molybdenum and tungsten exhibit very similar ionic radii due to the lanthanide-contraction effect. Molybdenum and/or tungsten are widely used in nature in the form of dithioleno metallopterin cofactors of enzymes that catalyze either two-electron oxidation-reduction of oxoanion or organic metabolites or non-redox (de)hydration reactions. The four classes of these enzymes: the sulfite oxidase family, the xanthine oxidase family, the DMSO reductase family, and the aldehyde oxidoreductase (AOR) family, together are associated with all three domains of life. 4 Tungsten variants predominate in the fourth class, with a strong representation in the archaeal domain and with no eukaryal examples.The hyperthermophilic anaerobic archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus exhibits optimal growth at 100 • C apparently with an absolute dependence on the presence of tungstate. 5 Its tungsten proteome encompasses five AORs plus intracellular free tungstate. 6 Tungsten is also transiently bound to components of the biosynthetic machinery of tungstopterin 7 and to an ABC transporter named Wtp (tungsten transport protein). The soluble oxoanion binding protein of the latter exhibits a high selectivity for tungstate (K D ª 10 -11 M) over molybdate (K D ª 10 -8 M). 8 The structural and electronic basis of this selectivity is not understood, but it appears to be related to an unusual quasi-octahedral coordination of the metal that is induced upon binding of the oxoanions to the WtpA involving one oxygen each of the carboxylate side chains of an aspartate and a glutamate residue as discovered in the crystal structure of the WtpA from Archaeoglobus fulgidus. 9 The proposal of mononuclear quasi-octahedral MoO 6 and WO 6 units in proteins incited a stir in the bioinorganic community around the fundamental question whether such a structure would be likely, and if so, whether the formal metal oxidation state of VI would be a stable one. The quasi-octahedral coordination was recently corroborated in increased-resolution crystallographic studies on the tungstate complexes of WtpA from P. furiosus, A. fulgidus and other species, combined with EXAFS measurements on the A. fulgidus protein (Fig. 1). 10 The structure bears some resemblance to the monomeric trioxometal(VI) unit in LMO 3 (M = Mo, W; L = cyclic triamine). 11,12 Both structures are stabilized by an extensive hydrogen-bonding network. 10,12 Here, we address the question of stable oxidation states of the metals in this unusual metalloprotein. The tungstate and the molybdate complex of P. furiosus WtpA were extensively checked with EPR spectroscopy and they were found to be EPR silent. Also, incubation of apo WtpA with tungstate in the presence of the spin trap DMPO did not afford a radical s...