The Unintended Consequences of Social Media in Healthcare: New Problems and New Solutions

Abstract

SummaryObjectives: Social media is increasingly being used in conjunction with health information technology (health IT). The objective of this paper is to identify some of the undesirable outcomes that arise from this integration and to suggest solutions to these problems. Methodology: After a discussion with experts to elicit the topics that should be included in the survey, we performed a narrative review based on recent literature and interviewed multidisciplinary experts from different areas. In each case, we identified and analyzed the unintended effects of social media in health IT. Results: Each analyzed topic provided a different set of unintended consequences. Most relevant consequences include lack of privacy with ethical and legal issues, patient confusion in disease management, poor information accuracy in crowdsourcing, unclear responsibilities, misleading and biased information in the prevention and detection of epidemics, and demotivation in gamified health solutions with social components. Conclusions: Using social media in healthcare offers several benefits, but it is not exempt of potential problems, and not all of these problems have clear solutions. We recommend careful design of digital systems in order to minimize patient's feelings of demotivation and frustration and we recommend following specific guidelines that should be created by all stakeholders in the healthcare ecosystem.

Balancing Between Privacy and Patient Needs for Health Information in the Age of Participatory Health and Social Media: A Scoping Review

“…Whilst the collective intelligence surrounding the various uses and applications of social media and mobile technology in health is on the rise, the evidence-based research for social media's effectiveness to improve health outcomes remains relatively immature 2 . Several compelling arguments exist for why evidence needs to continue to grow, including the need to examine not only perceived positives, but also to unpack any potential negatives or unintended consequences of using social media 1 7 . This has been a core focus of the work of the members of the International Medical Informatics Association - Participatory Health and Social Media Working Group (IMIA PHSM), many of whom are authors of this manuscript.…”

“…This has been a core focus of the work of the members of the International Medical Informatics Association - Participatory Health and Social Media Working Group (IMIA PHSM), many of whom are authors of this manuscript. Of primary significance to this Yearbook theme, the working group's previous work has noted that ethical issues related to social media, such as privacy and confidentiality, are key areas warranting further research 1 7 .…”

Outcomes in Child Health: Exploring the Use of Social Media to Engage Parents in Patient-Centered Outcomes Research

“…Along with its widespread use among health professionals and patients, the body of published literature examining the role of social media in health care is growing. Recent systematic review data have underscored the potential benefits, ethical issues, and unintended consequences of using social media in the health care environment [ 5 - 7 ]. For example, although online communities may represent an important source of social and emotional support for patients, participation in such communities may also result in diminished subjective well-being (eg, increased anxiety), and invoke concerns for privacy.…”

Building Standardized and Secure Mobile Health Services Based on Social Media

“…However, in spite of the promising benefits of social-media-based healthcare, there are some challenges still to be solved. Most of those issues are linked to privacy and security concerns, but there are also open questions about usability, manipulation of identity, governance or confidentiality, along with the aforementioned demotivation [9,14,15].…”