The use and reporting of airline passenger data for infectious disease modelling: a systematic review

Abstract

Background A variety of airline passenger data sources are used for modelling the international spread of infectious diseases. Questions exist regarding the suitability and validity of these sources. Aim We conducted a systematic review to identify the sources of airline passenger data used for these purposes and to assess validation of the data and reproducibility of the methodology. Methods Articles matching our search criteria and describing a model of the international spread of human infectious disease, parameterised with airline passenger data, were identified. Information regarding type and source of airline passenger data used was collated and the studies’ reproducibility assessed. Results We identified 136 articles. The majority (n = 96) sourced data primarily used by the airline industry. Governmental data sources were used in 30 studies and data published by individual airports in four studies. Validation of passenger data was conducted in only seven studies. No study was found to be fully reproducible, although eight were partially reproducible. Limitations By limiting the articles to international spread, articles focussed on within-country transmission even if they used relevant data sources were excluded. Authors were not contacted to clarify their methods. Searches were limited to articles in PubMed, Web of Science and Scopus. Conclusion We recommend greater efforts to assess validity and biases of airline passenger data used for modelling studies, particularly when model outputs are to inform national and international public health policies. We also recommend improving reporting standards and more detailed studies on biases in commercial and open-access data to assess their reproducibility.

Dengue importation into Europe: A network connectivity-based approach

“…Previous work on network-mediated epidemic often assumes a common framework, that the probability of an imported infection is directly correlated with the number of arriving air passengers [13,21]. However, a simple correlation between imported cases and crude travel statistics is insufficient to explain the transmission pathways [21]. Such an approach does not allow to differentiate imported cases arriving from countries with higher infection risk and transport potential, or if the variance in the number of cases is also mediated by other socioeconomic and anthropogenic factors.…”

Tracking the Wings of Covid-19 by Modeling Adaptability with Open Mobility Data

“…Two reviews, one presented by Findlater and Bogoch (2018) illustrating how rapid movement around the globe facilitate epidemics in different viruses (e.g., Zika, SARS, Dengue) and the other by Desai et al (2019) evidencing the role of forecasting methodologies and the importance of data in outbreak events. Unfortunately, most of the aviation data is not public, having implications in reproducibility and extension of the use of these models in global disasters faced today (Li and Ryerson 2019;Meslé et al 2019).…”

Modelling the global spread of diseases: A review of current practice and capability

“…We consider validation to be done by comparing model predictions to a known outcome or, more weakly, by calibrating a model to a known outcome. Data validation of disease spread models has been discussed in Meslé et al (2018).…”