The use of data for planning and service improvement in Tanzanian Primary healthcare facilities: Experience from Star Rating Assessment

Abstract

Background The use of data for planning and improving healthcare delivery is sub-optimal among developing countries. In 2015, Tanzania started to implement Star Rating Assessment (SRA) process for primary health care (PHC) facilities to improve various dimensions of quality of services, including the use of data. We aimed at assessing the extent and predictors of data use in Tanzanian PHC facilities. Methodology We used the most current national SRA data available in DHIS2 that was collected in 2017/2018 from all 7,289 PHC facilities. A facility was considered using data if gained 80% of the allocated scores. Other dependent variables were the three components that together contribute to the use of data [If PHC facility has Health Management Information systems (HMIS) functional, disseminate information, and has proper medical records]. We determined the association between data use and facility ownership status (public or private), location of the facility (rural or urban) and facility service level (dispensary, health centre or hospital). Results are presented as proportions of facilities that qualified for data use and the three components. The associations are reported in Adjusted odds ratio (AOR) with a 95% confidence interval (CI). Results A total of 6,663(91.4%) PHC facilities met our inclusion criteria for analysis. Among the facilities: 1,198(18.0%) had used data for planning and services improvement; 3,792(56.9%) had functional HMIS; 1,752(26.3%) had disseminated data; and 631(9.5%) had proper medical records. PHC facilities that are publicly owned (AOR 1.25; 95% CI: 1.05–1.48) and those at higher service level [hospitals (AOR 1.77; 95% CI: 1.27–2.46) and health centres (AOR 1.39; 95% CI: 1.15–1.68) compared to dispensaries] were more likely to use data. Conclusion The use of facility data for planning and services improvement in Tanzanian PHC facilities is low, and much effort needs to be targeted at privately-owned and low-level PHC facilities.

How Zanzibar's Health Services Fund Can Learn from Lower and Middle Income Countries to Achieve Universal Health Coverage: A Blueprint for Success

“…This will enable effective delivery of healthcare services and ensure sustainability in the long run. (19) (20) (21) In addition, it is advised that the Zanzibar Health Services Fund give top priority to achieving a high coverage rate by interacting with marginalized people and making sure that healthcare services are affordable and available to everybody in order to stop health inequities. (22) The ZHSF must also guarantee accountability and openness in the fund's administration.…”

Determinants of COVID-19 data quality in the District Health Information Management System version 2 in Ahafo Region, Ghana

“…Similarly, as of May 1, 2020, the United States of America lacked a standardized system for COVID-19 data reporting, leading to significant discrepancies in data quality among different states and counties (8,10). Although there is no perfect health data due to missing values, bias, measurement, transcription, and human entry errors, most of these data problems chiefly occur in developing countries (11)(12)(13)(14). Poor data quality in the health sector can be attributed to various factors, including inadequate training of data managers and healthcare staff, limited access to resources such as technology and reporting tools, and data fragmentation due to disparate systems (2,11,15,16).…”