The vulnerable healthcare consumer: an interpretive synthesis of the patient experience literature

Abstract

The increased policy emphasis on the ‘patient experience’ places the health consumer in centre stage as the driver for healthcare delivery. This poses challenges for service providers to meet the needs of more vulnerable groups, notably those with disabilities, who are often more likely to be both in greater need of services and, at the same time, less able to access them. This paper reports an interpretive synthesis of qualitative research studies in the UK and US on the experience of vulnerable patient groups using a broad range of health services. An interpretive review method was adopted to capture the complexity of the data. Eighteen papers were identified as meeting the inclusion criteria for the review. Seven key themes were identified: life experience, service design, point of delivery, accessibility, availability, specialist education/training and consumer typology. Although policy makers and providers often refer to the need for greater consumerism in the development of health services, our review suggests that it may be appropriate to consider a model of ‘mediated consumerism’ for some groups of service users. While some concerns are common to both mainstream and vulnerable consumers, others such as accessibility of services, and the resulting experience of health care, are particular to specific vulnerable groups. Accessing the experiences of these more vulnerable groups therefore warrants close attention in the development of both policy and practice in health service delivery.

Differences in mobile health app use: A source of new digital inequalities?

“…Two, our findings provide a critical backdrop against which to assess strategies, such as the European e-health strategies, which tend to differentiate little between different types of users. Here, it is important to bear in mind that certain consumers are probably better positioned to self-manage their health (e.g., the "average" e-health consumers who is young, highly educated, and e-health literate) than other more "vulnerable" consumers (for a more in-depth discussion on the notions of "average" and "vulnerable" consumer, see Baker, Gentry, and Rittenberg 2005;Duivenvoorde 2014;Hare, Law, and Brennan 2012;Incardona and Poncib o 2007;London Economics, VVA Consulting, and Ipsos Mori 2016). Moreover, with the increasing "datafication" and "commodification" of health data through online health platforms, users are increasingly challenged to identify trustworthy versus less trustworthy actors in this sector (Andrejevic 2014;Van Dijck and Poell 2016).…”

Consumer rights of the elderly as vulnerable consumers in South Africa: some comparative aspects of the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008

“…Brennan and Coppack (2008) argue that the language of consumer empowerment is gaining prominence in policy and strategy documents at the highest levels internationally. Hare et al (2013) argue, by referring in particular to health service delivery to vulnerable consumer groups (such as the elderly), that accessing the experiences of these more vulnerable groups warrants close attention in the development of both policy and practice. Broderick et al (2011) reminds us that failure by suppliers and marketers to adequately accommodate groups that experience situational or enduring vulnerability can have severe consequences.…”

Genomic Privacy and Direct-to-Consumer Genetics: Big Consumer Genetic Data -- What's in that Contract?

“…However, there is growing interest in the concept of the vulnerable consumer and this debate has relevance in the DTCGT context, as it is possible to argue that at least some DTCGT consumers should be viewed as vulnerable. 5 This will be explored further in subsequent work.…”