The Whole Is Other Than the Sum of Its Parts: Sensibility Analysis of 360° Urban Image Splitting

Abstract

Abstract. 360° imagery has been increasingly used to estimate the subjective qualities of the urban space, such as the feeling of safety or the liveliness of a place. These spherical panoramas offer an immersive view of the urban scene, close to the experience of a pedestrian. In recent years, Deep Learning approaches have been developed for this estimation task, only using flat images because these images are easier to annotate and process with standard CNNs. Thus to qualify the whole urban space, the panoramic images are divided into four flat sub-images that can be processed by the trained neural networks. The sub-images cover the 360° field of view, e.g. front, back, left, and right views. The four scores obtained are averaged to represent the level of the quality at the location of the panorama. However, this split introduces a bias since some elements of the urban space are halved over two images and the global context is lost. Based on the Place Pulse 2.0 dataset, this paper investigates the impact of splitting 360° panoramas on the perceptual scores predicted by neural networks. For each panorama, we predict the score for thirty-six overlapping sub-images. The scores were shown to have high variability and be highly dependent on the direction of the camera for the perspective images. This indicates that four images are not sufficient to capture the complexity of the perceptual qualities of the urban space.

Appraisal of Architectural Ambiances in a Future District

“…This review highlights the prevalence of Google Street View data in urban analytics research across various domains, ranging from analyzing vegetation and transportation to health and socio-economic studies. Both machine learning algorithms [9][10][11][12] and human participants [13] can process still images derived from street view imagery.…”