In cluster studies, the isoelectronic replacement strategy has been successfully used to introduce new elements into a known structure while maintaining the desired topology. The well-known penta-atomic 18 valence electron (ve) species CAl 2 − 4 and its Al − /Si or Al/Si + isoelectronically replaced clusters CAl 3 Si − , CAl 2 Si 2 , CAlSi − 3 , and CSi 2 + 4 , all possess the same anti-van't Hoff/Le Bel skeletons, that is, nontraditional planar tetracoordinate carbon (ptC) structure. In this article, however, we found that such isoelectronic replacement between Si and Al does not work for the 16ve-CAl 4 with the traditional van't Hoff/Le Bel tetrahedral carbon (thC) and its isoelectronic derivatives CAl 3 X (X = Ga/In/Tl). At the level of CCSD(T)/ def2-QZVP//B3LYP/def2-QZVP, none of the global minima of the 16ve mono-Si-containing clusters CAl 2 SiX + (X = Al/Ga/In/Tl) maintains thC as the parent CAl 4 does. Instead, X = Al/Ga globally favors an unusual ptC structure that has one long C─X distance yet with significant bond index value, and X = In/Tl prefers the planar tricoordinate carbon. The frustrated formation of thC in these clusters is ascribed to the C Si bonding that prefers a planar fashion. Inclusion of chloride ion would further stabilize the ptC of CAl 2 SiAl + and CAl 2 SiGa + . The unexpectedly disclosed CAl 2 SiAl + and CAl 2 SiGa + represent the first type of 16ve-cationic ptCs with multiple bonds.