The
stability and the structure of adducts formed between four
substituted phosphanes (PX3, X:H, F, Cl, and NMe2) and 11 different carbenes have been investigated by DFT calculations.
In most cases, the structure of the adducts depends strongly on the
stability of the carbene itself, exhibiting a linear correlation with
the increasing dissociation energy of the adduct. Carbenes of low
stability form phosphorus ylides (F), which can be described
as phosphane → carbene adducts supported with some back-bonding.
The most stable carbenes, which have high energy lone pair, do not
form stable F-type structures but carbene → phosphane
adducts (E-type structure), utilizing the low-lying lowest
unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the phosphane (with electronegative
substituents), benefiting also from the carbene–pnictogen interaction.
Especially noteworthy is the case of PCl3, which has an
extremely low energy LUMO in its T-shaped form. Although this PCl3 structure is a transition state of rather high energy, the
large stabilization energy of the complex makes this carbene–phosphane
adduct stable. Most interestingly, in case of carbenes with medium
stability both F- and E-type structures
could be optimized, giving rise to bond-stretch isomerism. Likewise,
for phosphorus ylides (F), the stability of the adducts G formed from carbenes with hypovalent phosphorus (PXphosphinidene)
is in a linear relationship with the stabilization of the carbene.
Adducts of carbenes with hypervalent phosphorus (PX5) are
the most stable when X is electronegative, and the carbene is highly
nucleophilic.