To reveal the relative importance of charge doping and defect scattering in substitutionally modified 122 iron pnictides, we perform a systematic first principles study on selected bands at the Fermi level. Disorder effects are induced by various substitutions using an orbital based coherent potential approximation (CPA). Pronounced level shifts of individual bands suggest that transition metal substitutions introduce mobile charge carriers into the system. However, important deviations from such a rigid band scenario as well as spectral broadenings due to impurity scattering correlate with the band character. Finally a T -matrix analysis exhibits a larger intraband than interband scattering consistent with an s +− pairing state. Comparing different substitutions reveals an increase of pair-breaking along the transition metal series.PACS numbers: 74.70. Xa, 74.62.Dh, 71.15.Mb, Chemical substitution is an important tuning parameter which governs the phase diagram and thus the onset of superconductivity in the various iron pnictide superconductors. Despite intensive experimental and theoretical work on a variety of different families of these compounds for more than half a decade by now, the role of substitutional disorder is still under debate. In particular the substitution of Fe by other 3d transition metals (TM) in the 122-family such as BaFe 2 As 2 has been discussed controversially. Macroscopic measurements over a range of compositions [1] suggest that the number of extra d electrons at the TM site is the decisive quantity which determines the shape of the superconducting dome for TM ∈ {Co,Ni}. Such a rigid-band-shift scenario is also compatible with changes of Fermi surfaces as observed in angular resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) [2,3]. On the other hand, X-ray absorption measurements (NEXAFS) [4] see at best a small change of valence at the Fe atom induced by TM substitution, which challenges the view of a rigid band shift. This finding is also consistent with the dependence of the Néel temperature on chemical substitution reported in [1]. From the viewpoint of electronic structure calculations this dichotomy between localized extra electrons and doping into conduction bands has been first addressed by supercell calculations [5,6]. More recently, effective medium approaches, which can handle arbitrary impurity concentrations, have been used to study the effect of substitutional disorder on bandstructure and Fermi surface topology [7,8]. Nevertheless a systematic first principles investigation of different substitutions on the behavior of electronic quasiparticles is still lacking.A further aspect of substitutional disorder is its impact on the superconducting state. It is widely accepted that these systems are unconventional superconductors where impurity scattering is important for Cooper pairbreaking [9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16] In this Letter we performed electronic structure calculations of substitutionally disordered iron based systems to address these topics. We focus on disorderinduced...