Catalytic transformations play a vital role in the implementation
of chemical technologies, particularly as society shifts from fossil-fuel-based
feedstocks to more renewable bio-based systems. The dehydration of
short-chain alcohols using solid acid catalysts is of great interest
for the fuel, polymer, and pharmaceutical industries. Microporous
frameworks, such as aluminophosphates, are well-suited to such processes,
as their framework channels and pores are a similar size to the small
alcohols considered, with many different topologies to consider. However,
the framework and acid site strength are typically linked, making
it challenging to study just one of these factors. In this work, we
compare two different silicon-doped aluminophosphates, SAPO-34 and
SAPO-5, for alcohol dehydration with the aim of decoupling the influence
of acid site strength and the influence of confinement, both of which
are key factors in nanoporous catalysis. By varying the alcohol size
from ethanol, 1-propanol, and 2-propanol, the acid sites are constant,
while the confinement is altered. The experimental catalytic dehydration
results reveal that the small-pore SAPO-34 behaves differently to
the larger-pore SAPO-5. The former primarily forms alkenes, while
the latter favors ether formation. Combining our catalytic findings
with density functional theory investigations suggests that the formation
of surface alkoxy species plays a pivotal role in the reaction pathway,
but the exact energy barriers are strongly influenced by pore structure.
To provide a holistic view of the reaction, our work is complemented
with molecular dynamics simulations to explore how the diffusion of
different species plays a key role in product selectivity, specifically
focusing on the role of ether mobility in influencing the reaction
mechanism. We conclude that confinement plays a significant role in
molecular diffusion and the reaction mechanism translating to notable
catalytic differences between the molecules, providing valuable information
for future catalyst design.