Therapists’ attitudes towards the use of AI in therapeutic practice: considering the therapeutic alliance

Abstract

Purpose The aim of this research is to gain an insight into the attitudes that therapists, both qualified and trainee, have towards the use of artificial intelligence (AI)/machine therapy in therapeutic practice. The paper also aims to gain an insight into attitudes towards machine therapy and the potential of developing a therapeutic alliance with a machine therapist. Design/methodology/approach A short questionnaire was developed to gauge therapists and trainee therapists’ attitudes towards machine therapy. The questionnaire included a scenario for participants to read and then respond to questions on the therapeutic alliance using questions based upon those asked on the working alliance short inventory scale. At the end of the questionnaire, there was also the opportunity for participants to respond to an open-ended question. Findings It is evident from the responses that there is a clear reservation about the use of AI technology within the therapeutic setting. In spite of this reticence, many participants recognised the potential and are open to the possibilities this technology can bring. It was notable that the therapists largest concern was about the potential to create a strong bond with a machine therapist. Originality/value This paper presents findings on therapists’ attitudes towards AI use within therapeutic practice and machine therapy. Whilst limited in scope, it provides a yardstick for considering the way that attitudes towards these emerging technologies might change in the future.

Large language models could change the future of behavioral healthcare: a proposal for responsible development and evaluation

“…With respect to applications of AI to augment supervision and support for psychotherapy, therapists have expressed concern about privacy, the ability to detect subtle non-verbal cues and cultural responsiveness, and the impact on therapist confidence, but they also see benefits for training and professional growth 68 . Other research suggests that while therapists believe AI can increase access to care, allow individuals to disclose embarrassing information more comfortably, continuously refine therapeutic techniques 69 , they have concerns about privacy and the formation of a strong therapeutic bond with machine-based therapeutic interventions 70 . Involvement of individuals who will be referring their patients and using LLMs in their own practice will be essential to developing solutions they can trust and implement, and to make sure these solutions have the features that support trust and usability (simple interfaces, accurate summaries of AI-patient interactions, etc.).…”

The use of artificial intelligence in mental health services in Turkey: What do mental health professionals think?

“…For example, in recent studies on the opinions of mental health professionals, those who did not have AI experience tended to approach therapeutic interventions with AI with caution (J. Prescott & Hanley, 2023). Notably, experience in AIsupported psychotherapy may change cautious attitudes toward such practices (Aktan et al, 2022).…”