Using the Wolff and geometric cluster Monte Carlo methods, we investigate the tricritical Blume-Capel model in three dimensions. Since these simulations conserve the number of vacancies and thus effectively introduce a constraint, we generalize the Fisher renormalization for constrained critical behavior to tricritical systems. We observe that, indeed, the tricritical behavior is significantly modified under this constraint. For instance, at tricriticality, the specific heat has only a finite cusp and the Binder ratio assumes a different value from that in unconstrained systems. Since 3 is the upper tricritical dimensionality of Ising systems, we expect that the mean-field theory correctly predicts a number of universal parameters in three dimensions. Therefore, we calculate the partition sum of the mean-field tricritical Blume-Capel model, and accordingly obtain the exact value of the Binder ratio. Under the constraint, we show that this mean-field tricritical system reduces to the mean-field critical Ising model. However, our three-dimensional data do not agree with this mean-field prediction. Instead, they are successfully explained by the generalized Fisher renormalization mechanism.