The use of thermoplastic elastomers with conductive fillers enables to produce strain sensors in a variety of shapes and forms by using thermoplastic processing routes. However, some methods of thermoplastic processing are costly and require long production time. Filament printing, an additive manufacturing route that still exhibits a high annual growth rate, is a cost and time-efficient method of additive processing. In this study a commercial conductive thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) based fused deposition modelling (FDM) filament and a styrenic block co-polymer (TPS) compound were extruded through two different FDM based nozzles sizes, using an FDM 3D printer. The TPU material could only be extruded through a 0.5 mm orifice, using a lower nozzle diameter resulted in a none-elastic brittle filament. For the TPS material it was possible to produce filaments with diameter 0.3 mm and 0.5 mm. In all dynamic tests, the extruded commercial piezoresistive TPU filament either showed at higher elongation plastic deformation, which resulted in resistance uncertainty at low strain, or a secondary peak in the resistivity measurement. For the TPS material, mainly the relaxation of the material resulted in lagging of the resistive value at low strain, because of the buckling of the fiber. Using combined dynamic and static measurements, a reproducible signal could be achieved with the TPS based material, while the TPU based material could not be used as a sensor in this area of strains.