“They cared about us students:” learning from exemplar clinical teaching environments

Abstract

Purpose In order to foster positive student experiences in the clinical learning environment, we wanted to better understand which teaching practices they regard highly. Methods In 2016, the authors undertook a paper ‘exemplar’ survey (ES) of all fifth year medical students at one tertiary teaching site. Students had experienced all assigned clinical rotations over a two year period. Following a 66% response rate, we identified two clear exemplar clinical areas (ECAs). Over 2016–7, six focus groups with multidisciplinary staff members from these clinical areas were held, with the aim to identify, discuss and understand their specific teaching practices in more detail. Results The authors present descriptions of positive student experiences and related staff practices, in five themes. Themes emerged around foundational logistic and personal factors: central to student and staff data is that ‘welcome’ on a daily, and ongoing basis, can be foundational to learning. Central to ECA staff data are universal practices by which all staff purposefully work to develop a functional staff-student relationship and play a part in organising/teaching students. Students and ECA staff groups both understood teacher values to be central to student learning and that cultivating a student’s values is one of their major educational tasks. Conclusions The framework formed by this thematic analysis is useful, clear and transferrable to other clinical teaching contexts. It also aligns with current thinking about best supporting student learning and cultivating student values as part of developing professionalism. Instigating such practices might help to optimise clinical teaching. We also tentatively suggest that such practices might help where resources are scarce, and perhaps also help ameliorate student bullying. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1186/s12909-019-1551-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Supporting Bystanders and Other Staff Exposed to Negative Workplace Behaviour: Developing and Testing the IMO Intervention Framework in the Clinical Workplace

“…Specifically, that our approach should avoid a department, profession or staff group feeling “targeted.” Instead, we carefully framed the intervention as a gratis staff development and research opportunity. 25 , 30 …”

Ten maxims for creating a safe learning environment

“…Students are more attentive, ask more questions, and are more actively engaged in such an environment (33). Importantly, it has also been shown that a student in such a relationship can go on to develop a sense that their teacher is credible and, therefore, an invaluable asset to their learning (13,35). Relationships are verily the most vital of determinants in creating an educational climate conducive to learning.…”